Amazon Kindle removes download feature of purchased books: Difference between revisions
cleaned up and removed duplicate content in roald dahl censorship section, made subheadings for navigation |
added a link |
||
(18 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[File:Fyi-amazon-is-removing-download-transfer-option-on-feb-26th-v0-s7wd6fm1rqie1.webp|alt=Amazon notice about removing download capability|thumb|Amazon notice about removing download capability <ref>https://www.reddit.com/r/kindle/comments/1inr9uy/fyi_amazon_is_removing_download_transfer_option/</ref>]] | [[File:Fyi-amazon-is-removing-download-transfer-option-on-feb-26th-v0-s7wd6fm1rqie1.webp|alt=Amazon notice about removing download capability|thumb|Amazon notice about removing download capability.<ref name=":0">{{Cite web|url=https://www.reddit.com/r/kindle/comments/1inr9uy/fyi_amazon_is_removing_download_transfer_option/|title=FYI Amazon is removing Download & Transfer option on Feb 26th|format=forum thread|publisher=Reddit|language=en|date=12 Feb 2025}}</ref>]] | ||
On February 26th 2025, [[Amazon]] removed the "download and transfer via USB" feature from their website. This means [[Amazon Kindle]] users are no longer able to download their purchased e-books from Amazon's website to their computers using the "download and transfer via USB" feature. A message describing this change appeared on the page for the download feature a few weeks before the feature was removed.<ref name="theverge">{{Cite web|url=https://www.theverge.com/news/612898/amazon-removing-kindle-book-download-transfer-usb|title=Amazon’s killing a feature that let you download and backup Kindle books|publisher=The Verge|date=14 Feb 2025|format=article|author=Andrew Liszewski|language=en}}</ref> | |||
==Background== | ==Background== | ||
Amazon allows purchasing e-books on their platform. These e-books are designed to be used with Amazon Kindle devices and the Kindle app. The "download and transfer via USB" feature | Amazon allows purchasing e-books on their platform. These e-books are designed to be used with Amazon Kindle devices and the Kindle app. The "download and transfer via USB" feature allowed users to download purchased e-books on their computers. The intended use for this was to allow people to transfer e-books from their computer to their Kindle, without requiring the Kindle to have an internet connection. The "download and transfer via USB" feature was available since the early days of Kindle, when many devices didn't have Wi-Fi capabilities, such as the Kindle 1, Kindle 2, and Kindle DX.<ref name=":1">{{Cite web|url=https://wiki.mobileread.com/wiki/Amazon_Kindle_1|publisher=MobileRead Wiki|title=Amazon Kindle 1|language=en|format=wiki page|date=21 Nov 2011}} | ||
</ref> | </ref><ref name=":2">{{Cite web|url=https://wiki.mobileread.com/wiki/Amazon_Kindle_2|title=Amazon Kindle 2|publisher=MobileRead Wiki|language=en|format=wiki page|date=21 Nov 2011}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web|url=https://wiki.mobileread.com/wiki/Kindle_DX|date=15 Apr 2014|title=Kindle DX|format=wiki page|publisher=MobileRead Wiki|language=en}}</ref> | ||
===Reasons | ===Reasons For Feature=== | ||
* | *Allowed users to transfer books to Kindles without an internet connection. Older devices may no longer be able to connect | ||
* | *Let users create backup copies of their purchased e-book library | ||
* | *Provided a way to access books in the older AZW3 format, which is more amenable to format conversion than newer formats due to less restrictive DRM | ||
* | *Gave users more control over their purchased content | ||
===DRM implications=== | ===DRM implications=== | ||
As well as the intended usage, customers | As well as the intended usage, customers used this feature to create backups of their Kindle libraries and to convert the e-books to other formats to use with non-Kindle devices. Amazon Kindle e-readers use a proprietary format to store e-books, and a lot of the e-books contain [[Digital rights management|DRM]], which needs to be removed to use the e-books with non-Kindle devices. Newer Kindle devices use the KFX format, which makes it almost impossible to remove DRM. Since the download and transfer feature used the older AZW3 format, people with newer Kindles could use this feature to download their e-books in a format where the DRM can be removed.<ref name="theverge" /> | ||
==Removal of download and transfer via USB== | ==Removal of download and transfer via USB== | ||
In February 2025, Amazon added a notice next to the download button whenever | In February 2025, Amazon added a notice next to the download button whenever users accessed the "download and transfer via USB" feature. This notice said that the feature would be removed on February 26th. After that day, customers were no longer able to download their purchased e-books from the Amazon website. | ||
Customers | Customers are still be able to download e-books to their Kindles, but have to either use the Kindle store on the device or use the "Deliver or Remove from Device" option on the Amazon website.<ref name="theverge" /> Both of these options require the e-reader to have an internet connection. | ||
This isn't the first time Amazon has made changes affecting customers' access to their purchased e-books. For instance, Amazon previously removed books customers had purchased since the company that uploaded them didn't have the rights to the content.<ref>https://goodereader.com/blog/kindle/amazon-is-not-to-be-trusted-anymore-with-their-kindle-e-reader</ref> | This isn't the first time Amazon has made changes affecting customers' access to their purchased e-books. For instance, Amazon previously removed books customers had purchased since the company that uploaded them didn't have the rights to the content.<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://goodereader.com/blog/kindle/amazon-is-not-to-be-trusted-anymore-with-their-kindle-e-reader|title=Amazon is not to be trusted anymore with their Kindle e-reader|date=14 Feb 2025|publisher=Good e-Reader|format=article|language=en|author=Michael Kozlowski}}</ref> | ||
==Customer response== | ==Customer response== | ||
This change has caused significant backlash from customers.<ref | This change has caused significant backlash from customers.<ref name=":0" /><ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMoCzeGnIss|title=Amazon are changing the way you own your Kindle books - you have 10 days to react|date=16 Feb 2025|publisher=YouTube|author=CriminOlly|format=video|language=en}}</ref> This is due to the following reasons: | ||
*The change makes it much harder for customers to read e-books they have purchased on non-Kindle devices | *The change makes it much harder for customers to read e-books they have purchased on non-Kindle devices | ||
*Customers are now required to connect their Kindle e-readers to the internet if they want to download books purchased on Amazon | *Customers are now required to connect their Kindle e-readers to the internet if they want to download books purchased on Amazon | ||
*The change makes it harder for customers to move away from Amazon to another e-book platform, since customers | *The change makes it harder for customers to move away from Amazon to another e-book platform, since customers are not able to keep the e-books they purchased through Amazon | ||
After the announcement, many consumers | After the announcement, many consumers downloaded their purchased e-books with the download and transfer feature while the feature was available. Many people have also moved to other providers to buy e-books going forward. | ||
Other users | Other users resorted to jailbreaking their devices to ensure continued access to previous features. This can be done using tools such as [https://kindlemodding.org/jailbreaking/WinterBreak/ WinterBreak], which allow users to run custom applications like [https://github.com/koreader/koreader/wiki/Installation-on-Kindle-devices KOReader], a unified eBook reader that supports PDF, DjVu, EPUB, FB2, and many other formats—on Cervantes, Kindle, Kobo, PocketBook, and Android devices. | ||
==Effect on Original Kindle Devices (Kindle 1 & Kindle | ==Effect on Original Kindle Devices (Kindle 1, Kindle 2, & Kindle DX)== | ||
The | The Amazon Kindle 1 (2007), Kindle 2 (2009), and Kindle DX (2009) relied on EVDO and 3G networks for wireless book downloads via Amazon’s Whispernet service.<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":2" /> However, with the global shutdown of these older networks by mobile carriers, these early Kindle models are no longer able to download purchased Kindle books wirelessly in most regions. | ||
Since eBooks can no longer be purchased from the Kindle Store and downloaded, there is no way to get them onto these devices. | |||
*Users | *Users are no longer be able to download Kindle books to a computer for manual transfer to their device via USB. | ||
* | *Kindle books that were downloaded before this date can still be transferred manually. | ||
*Any new purchases will require a | *Any new purchases will require a WiFi-enabled Kindle, a 4G-enabled Kindle or access to Amazon’s Kindle apps to read. | ||
* | *This effectively bricks older Kindles for the use case of reading newly purchased Kindle books | ||
====Remaining Functionality==== | ====Remaining Functionality==== | ||
*The Kindle 1 and Kindle | *The Kindle 1, Kindle 2, and Kindle DX still support USB file transfers for non-Amazon content, including: | ||
**DRM-free MOBI, PRC, and TXT files. | **DRM-free MOBI, PRC, and TXT files. | ||
**Converted EPUB files using tools like | **Converted EPUB files using tools like Calibre. | ||
**Public domain books from sites such as | **Public domain books from sites such as Project Gutenberg. | ||
*Users who backed up their Kindle books before the | *Users who backed up their Kindle books before the February 26, 2025 cutoff can still manually transfer them via USB. | ||
==Censorship & Content Replacement== | ==Censorship & Content Replacement== | ||
Line 61: | Line 58: | ||
<blockquote>When it came to children’s books, Dennison says Dahl didn’t care what adults thought as long as his target readers were happy. “‘I don’t give a b----r what grown-ups think,’ was a characteristic statement,” Dennison says. “And I’m almost certain that he would have recognised that alterations to his novels prompted by the political climate were driven by adults rather than children, and this always inspired derision, if not contempt, in Dahl. | <blockquote>When it came to children’s books, Dennison says Dahl didn’t care what adults thought as long as his target readers were happy. “‘I don’t give a b----r what grown-ups think,’ was a characteristic statement,” Dennison says. “And I’m almost certain that he would have recognised that alterations to his novels prompted by the political climate were driven by adults rather than children, and this always inspired derision, if not contempt, in Dahl. | ||
“He never, for example, had any truck with librarians who criticised his books as too frightening, lacking moral role models, negative in their portrayal of women, etc,” he continues. “Dahl wrote stories intended to kindle in children a lifelong love of reading and to remind them of the childhood wonderlands of magic and enchantment, aims in which he succeeded triumphantly. Adult anxieties about political niceties didn’t register in this outlook. This said, although Dahl could be unabashed in offending adults, he took pains never to alienate or make unhappy his child readers.” <ref> | “He never, for example, had any truck with librarians who criticised his books as too frightening, lacking moral role models, negative in their portrayal of women, etc,” he continues. “Dahl wrote stories intended to kindle in children a lifelong love of reading and to remind them of the childhood wonderlands of magic and enchantment, aims in which he succeeded triumphantly. Adult anxieties about political niceties didn’t register in this outlook. This said, although Dahl could be unabashed in offending adults, he took pains never to alienate or make unhappy his child readers.” <ref name=":3">{{Cite web|url=https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/02/17/roald-dahl-books-rewritten-offensive-matilda-witches-twits/|publisher=The Telegraph|title=Roald Dahl rewritten|date=24 Feb 2023|format=article|author1=Ed Cumming|author2=Abigail Buchanan|author3=Genevieve Holl-Allen|language=en}}</ref></blockquote> | ||
=== Roald Dahl | Spelling out what Dahl said above: "I don't give a bugger"<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://issuu.com/footlights/docs/depaul_-_the_witches|title=The Witches|publisher=The Theatre School at DePaul University (2011)|author=Roald Dahl|date=1983}}</ref> | ||
=== | ===Roald Dahl book edits=== | ||
In 2023, | ====Editing of content in customer's libraries==== | ||
In February 2023, Puffin were caught automatically updating Roald Dahl e-books previously purchased on Amazon with new "sanitized" versions that contained hundreds of changes to the original text. Users who had purchased the e-books before the changes were implemented found their copies automatically replaced with the edited versions, without being given a choice or notification beyond the updates themselves.<ref name="times1">{{Cite web|url=https://www.thetimes.com/article/roald-dahl-collection-books-changes-text-puffin-uk-2023-rm2622vl0|title=Roald Dahl ebooks ‘force censored versions on readers’ despite backlash|author1=Ben Ellery|author2=James Beal|date=25 February 2023|format=article|publisher=Times Media}}</ref> | |||
==== ''Changes to books in customer libraries:'' ==== | In 2023, The Telegraph reported that '''hundreds of changes''' were made to Roald Dahl’s classic children's books, including ''Charlie and the Chocolate Factory'', ''Matilda'', and ''The Witches''.<ref name=":3" /> These edits were performed by the publisher Puffin in collaboration with a group called '''Inclusive Minds''', with the stated goal of ensuring the books ''"can continue to be enjoyed by all today."'' | ||
====''Changes to books in customer libraries:''==== | |||
The changes included numerous alterations to the original text, such as: | The changes included numerous alterations to the original text, such as: | ||
*Replacing "fat" with "enormous" in describing Augustus Gloop | *Replacing "fat" with "enormous" in describing Augustus Gloop | ||
*Removing Miss Trunchbull's "great horsey face" description to just "face" | *Removing Miss Trunchbull's "great horsey face" description to just "face" | ||
*Modifying character occupations (e.g., changing a woman "working as a cashier" to "working as a top scientist") | *Modifying character occupations (e.g., changing a woman "working as a cashier" to "working as a top scientist") | ||
*Removing references to certain authors (e.g., replacing Joseph Conrad with Jane Austen in Matilda)<ref | *Removing references to certain authors (e.g., replacing Joseph Conrad with Jane Austen in Matilda)<ref name=":3" /> | ||
* | *Gender-neutral language – "Cloud-Men" in ''James and the Giant Peach'' were renamed "Cloud-People". | ||
* | *Removal of references to physical appearance – The "fat little brown mouse" in ''The Witches'' became simply "little brown mouse". | ||
* | *Sanitization of language – ''The Witches'' originally stated: "You must be mad, woman!" This was rephrashed to "You must be out of your mind!" | ||
Clarissa Aykroyd, a children's publishing professional, described the automatic updates as feeling "Orwellian," saying she assumed users would be given the option on whether to download the original version or the newly sanitized versions given how significant the changes were. The forced updates led her to become "weary of ebooks."<ref name="times1" /> | Clarissa Aykroyd, a children's publishing professional, described the automatic updates as feeling "Orwellian," saying she assumed users would be given the option on whether to download the original version or the newly sanitized versions given how significant the changes were. The forced updates led her to become "weary of ebooks."<ref name="times1" /> | ||
Line 87: | Line 86: | ||
These edits sparked debate over whether these changes were necessary updates or excessive censorship. Critics argue that altering the original language distorts an author's intent and removes historical context. | These edits sparked debate over whether these changes were necessary updates or excessive censorship. Critics argue that altering the original language distorts an author's intent and removes historical context. | ||
This example of '''posthumous editing of literature''' demonstrates a broader trend of '''corporate-controlled content revision''' where publishers, rather than readers, decide what is deemed acceptable, and people who buy ebooks exercise no real ownership over what they bought and paid for. | This example of '''posthumous editing of literature''' demonstrates a broader trend of '''corporate-controlled content revision''' where publishers, rather than readers, decide what is deemed acceptable, and people who buy ebooks exercise no real ownership over what they bought and paid for. | ||
==USB Restrictions== | |||
In 2023, Amazon changed how their Kindle devices interact with computers from a raw view of a file system using UMS ([[wikipedia:USB_mass_storage_device_class|USB Mass Storage]]) to a filtered view using the MTP ([[wikipedia:Media_Transfer_Protocol|Media Transfer Protocol]]).<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.mobileread.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4352640|publisher=MobileRead Forums|format=forum thread|date=31 Aug 2023|language=en|title=Kindle Scribe no longer connects as USB drive}}</ref> | |||
MTP requires support on the operating system. Amazon had to provide macOS software to communicate with Kindles,<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.mobileread.com/forums/showthread.php?t=364580|title=Amazon releases MTP USB File Manager for macOS|format=forum thread|publisher=MobileRead Forums|date=13 Nov 2024|language=en}}</ref> and even Windows users had some issues. This change made download and transfer more complex for newer devices. | |||
This change means that all files transferred to the device will have to pass through a software filter running on the device before being accepted. Currently, this filtering is ineffective as demonstrated by WinterBreak which uses the exposed HTML cache. Future software revisions can and will add restrictions, especially to "improve security." | |||
Amazon has been pushing for content to go through Send-To-Kindle<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.amazon.com/sendtokindle|publisher=Amazon|title=Send to Kindle page}}</ref> instead of USB. This allows Amazon to restrict the usage of Kindle devices to display illicit content. | |||
==Issue Summary== | ==Issue Summary== | ||
Line 94: | Line 102: | ||
*Ability of publishers to modify purchased content without user consent. | *Ability of publishers to modify purchased content without user consent. | ||
*Ability of publishers to remove purchased content without user consent | *Ability of publishers to remove purchased content without user consent | ||
* | *E-book platforms can be used to retroactively alter literary works, erasing historical context and the artist's original intent. | ||
*Ability of content providers to disable perfectly functioning devices from being usable post-sale. | *Ability of content providers to disable perfectly functioning devices from being usable post-sale. | ||
Line 103: | Line 111: | ||
==References== | ==References== | ||
{{reflist}} | {{reflist}} | ||
[[Category:Amazon Kindle]] | |||
[[Category: | |||
[[Category:Content modification]] | [[Category:Content modification]] | ||
[[Category:Digital rights management]] | [[Category:Digital rights management]] | ||
[[Category:Retroactively amended purchase]] | [[Category:Retroactively amended purchase]] | ||
[[Category:Articles based on videos]] | [[Category:Articles based on videos]] |
Latest revision as of 22:36, 8 April 2025

On February 26th 2025, Amazon removed the "download and transfer via USB" feature from their website. This means Amazon Kindle users are no longer able to download their purchased e-books from Amazon's website to their computers using the "download and transfer via USB" feature. A message describing this change appeared on the page for the download feature a few weeks before the feature was removed.[2]
Background[edit | edit source]
Amazon allows purchasing e-books on their platform. These e-books are designed to be used with Amazon Kindle devices and the Kindle app. The "download and transfer via USB" feature allowed users to download purchased e-books on their computers. The intended use for this was to allow people to transfer e-books from their computer to their Kindle, without requiring the Kindle to have an internet connection. The "download and transfer via USB" feature was available since the early days of Kindle, when many devices didn't have Wi-Fi capabilities, such as the Kindle 1, Kindle 2, and Kindle DX.[3][4][5]
Reasons For Feature[edit | edit source]
- Allowed users to transfer books to Kindles without an internet connection. Older devices may no longer be able to connect
- Let users create backup copies of their purchased e-book library
- Provided a way to access books in the older AZW3 format, which is more amenable to format conversion than newer formats due to less restrictive DRM
- Gave users more control over their purchased content
DRM implications[edit | edit source]
As well as the intended usage, customers used this feature to create backups of their Kindle libraries and to convert the e-books to other formats to use with non-Kindle devices. Amazon Kindle e-readers use a proprietary format to store e-books, and a lot of the e-books contain DRM, which needs to be removed to use the e-books with non-Kindle devices. Newer Kindle devices use the KFX format, which makes it almost impossible to remove DRM. Since the download and transfer feature used the older AZW3 format, people with newer Kindles could use this feature to download their e-books in a format where the DRM can be removed.[2]
Removal of download and transfer via USB[edit | edit source]
In February 2025, Amazon added a notice next to the download button whenever users accessed the "download and transfer via USB" feature. This notice said that the feature would be removed on February 26th. After that day, customers were no longer able to download their purchased e-books from the Amazon website.
Customers are still be able to download e-books to their Kindles, but have to either use the Kindle store on the device or use the "Deliver or Remove from Device" option on the Amazon website.[2] Both of these options require the e-reader to have an internet connection.
This isn't the first time Amazon has made changes affecting customers' access to their purchased e-books. For instance, Amazon previously removed books customers had purchased since the company that uploaded them didn't have the rights to the content.[6]
Customer response[edit | edit source]
This change has caused significant backlash from customers.[1][7] This is due to the following reasons:
- The change makes it much harder for customers to read e-books they have purchased on non-Kindle devices
- Customers are now required to connect their Kindle e-readers to the internet if they want to download books purchased on Amazon
- The change makes it harder for customers to move away from Amazon to another e-book platform, since customers are not able to keep the e-books they purchased through Amazon
After the announcement, many consumers downloaded their purchased e-books with the download and transfer feature while the feature was available. Many people have also moved to other providers to buy e-books going forward.
Other users resorted to jailbreaking their devices to ensure continued access to previous features. This can be done using tools such as WinterBreak, which allow users to run custom applications like KOReader, a unified eBook reader that supports PDF, DjVu, EPUB, FB2, and many other formats—on Cervantes, Kindle, Kobo, PocketBook, and Android devices.
Effect on Original Kindle Devices (Kindle 1, Kindle 2, & Kindle DX)[edit | edit source]
The Amazon Kindle 1 (2007), Kindle 2 (2009), and Kindle DX (2009) relied on EVDO and 3G networks for wireless book downloads via Amazon’s Whispernet service.[3][4] However, with the global shutdown of these older networks by mobile carriers, these early Kindle models are no longer able to download purchased Kindle books wirelessly in most regions.
Since eBooks can no longer be purchased from the Kindle Store and downloaded, there is no way to get them onto these devices.
- Users are no longer be able to download Kindle books to a computer for manual transfer to their device via USB.
- Kindle books that were downloaded before this date can still be transferred manually.
- Any new purchases will require a WiFi-enabled Kindle, a 4G-enabled Kindle or access to Amazon’s Kindle apps to read.
- This effectively bricks older Kindles for the use case of reading newly purchased Kindle books
Remaining Functionality[edit | edit source]
- The Kindle 1, Kindle 2, and Kindle DX still support USB file transfers for non-Amazon content, including:
- DRM-free MOBI, PRC, and TXT files.
- Converted EPUB files using tools like Calibre.
- Public domain books from sites such as Project Gutenberg.
- Users who backed up their Kindle books before the February 26, 2025 cutoff can still manually transfer them via USB.
Censorship & Content Replacement[edit | edit source]
Censorship of literature now involves the alteration of existing works to make them amenable to political correctness. One recent example is the editing of Roald Dahl's books to remove language deemed offensive or outdated, that did not align with the original author's intentions. As stated by Matthew Dennison, a biographer of the late author,
When it came to children’s books, Dennison says Dahl didn’t care what adults thought as long as his target readers were happy. “‘I don’t give a b----r what grown-ups think,’ was a characteristic statement,” Dennison says. “And I’m almost certain that he would have recognised that alterations to his novels prompted by the political climate were driven by adults rather than children, and this always inspired derision, if not contempt, in Dahl. “He never, for example, had any truck with librarians who criticised his books as too frightening, lacking moral role models, negative in their portrayal of women, etc,” he continues. “Dahl wrote stories intended to kindle in children a lifelong love of reading and to remind them of the childhood wonderlands of magic and enchantment, aims in which he succeeded triumphantly. Adult anxieties about political niceties didn’t register in this outlook. This said, although Dahl could be unabashed in offending adults, he took pains never to alienate or make unhappy his child readers.” [8]
Spelling out what Dahl said above: "I don't give a bugger"[9]
Roald Dahl book edits[edit | edit source]
Editing of content in customer's libraries[edit | edit source]
In February 2023, Puffin were caught automatically updating Roald Dahl e-books previously purchased on Amazon with new "sanitized" versions that contained hundreds of changes to the original text. Users who had purchased the e-books before the changes were implemented found their copies automatically replaced with the edited versions, without being given a choice or notification beyond the updates themselves.[10]
In 2023, The Telegraph reported that hundreds of changes were made to Roald Dahl’s classic children's books, including Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Matilda, and The Witches.[8] These edits were performed by the publisher Puffin in collaboration with a group called Inclusive Minds, with the stated goal of ensuring the books "can continue to be enjoyed by all today."
Changes to books in customer libraries:[edit | edit source]
The changes included numerous alterations to the original text, such as:
- Replacing "fat" with "enormous" in describing Augustus Gloop
- Removing Miss Trunchbull's "great horsey face" description to just "face"
- Modifying character occupations (e.g., changing a woman "working as a cashier" to "working as a top scientist")
- Removing references to certain authors (e.g., replacing Joseph Conrad with Jane Austen in Matilda)[8]
- Gender-neutral language – "Cloud-Men" in James and the Giant Peach were renamed "Cloud-People".
- Removal of references to physical appearance – The "fat little brown mouse" in The Witches became simply "little brown mouse".
- Sanitization of language – The Witches originally stated: "You must be mad, woman!" This was rephrashed to "You must be out of your mind!"
Clarissa Aykroyd, a children's publishing professional, described the automatic updates as feeling "Orwellian," saying she assumed users would be given the option on whether to download the original version or the newly sanitized versions given how significant the changes were. The forced updates led her to become "weary of ebooks."[10]
After lots of backlash, Puffin announced it would publish the classic collection of 17 Dahl texts alongside the edited versions. Puffin acknowledged "very real questions around how stories can be kept relevant for new generations" while giving readers "the choice to decide how they experience Roald Dahl's magical, marvelous stories."[10]
Debate Over Modern Censorship[edit | edit source]
These edits sparked debate over whether these changes were necessary updates or excessive censorship. Critics argue that altering the original language distorts an author's intent and removes historical context.
This example of posthumous editing of literature demonstrates a broader trend of corporate-controlled content revision where publishers, rather than readers, decide what is deemed acceptable, and people who buy ebooks exercise no real ownership over what they bought and paid for.
USB Restrictions[edit | edit source]
In 2023, Amazon changed how their Kindle devices interact with computers from a raw view of a file system using UMS (USB Mass Storage) to a filtered view using the MTP (Media Transfer Protocol).[11]
MTP requires support on the operating system. Amazon had to provide macOS software to communicate with Kindles,[12] and even Windows users had some issues. This change made download and transfer more complex for newer devices.
This change means that all files transferred to the device will have to pass through a software filter running on the device before being accepted. Currently, this filtering is ineffective as demonstrated by WinterBreak which uses the exposed HTML cache. Future software revisions can and will add restrictions, especially to "improve security."
Amazon has been pushing for content to go through Send-To-Kindle[13] instead of USB. This allows Amazon to restrict the usage of Kindle devices to display illicit content.
Issue Summary[edit | edit source]
This incident highlights the larger issue of content ownership and censorship:
- Ability of publishers to modify purchased content without user consent.
- Ability of publishers to remove purchased content without user consent
- E-book platforms can be used to retroactively alter literary works, erasing historical context and the artist's original intent.
- Ability of content providers to disable perfectly functioning devices from being usable post-sale.
See Also[edit | edit source]
References[edit | edit source]
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 "FYI Amazon is removing Download & Transfer option on Feb 26th" (forum thread). Reddit. 12 Feb 2025.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Andrew Liszewski (14 Feb 2025). "Amazon's killing a feature that let you download and backup Kindle books" (article). The Verge.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 "Amazon Kindle 1" (wiki page). MobileRead Wiki. 21 Nov 2011.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 "Amazon Kindle 2" (wiki page). MobileRead Wiki. 21 Nov 2011.
- ↑ "Kindle DX" (wiki page). MobileRead Wiki. 15 Apr 2014.
- ↑ Michael Kozlowski (14 Feb 2025). "Amazon is not to be trusted anymore with their Kindle e-reader" (article). Good e-Reader.
- ↑ CriminOlly (16 Feb 2025). "Amazon are changing the way you own your Kindle books - you have 10 days to react" (video). YouTube.
- ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 Ed Cumming; Abigail Buchanan; Genevieve Holl-Allen (24 Feb 2023). "Roald Dahl rewritten" (article). The Telegraph.
- ↑ Roald Dahl (1983). "The Witches". The Theatre School at DePaul University (2011).
- ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 Ben Ellery; James Beal (25 February 2023). "Roald Dahl ebooks 'force censored versions on readers' despite backlash" (article). Times Media.
- ↑ "Kindle Scribe no longer connects as USB drive" (forum thread). MobileRead Forums. 31 Aug 2023.
- ↑ "Amazon releases MTP USB File Manager for macOS" (forum thread). MobileRead Forums. 13 Nov 2024.
- ↑ "Send to Kindle page". Amazon.