Whistle pet tracker shutdown IoT fail: Difference between revisions

(4 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)

Line 40:

Tractive CEO Michael Hurnaus characterized the acquisition as enabling the company to ''"deliver new features and improvements faster, more reliably, and with greater impact for all users—including former Whistle customers."''<ref>{{cite web|url=https://finance.yahoo.com/news/tractive-acquires-whistle-mars-petcare-110000346.html|title=Tractive Acquires Whistle from Mars Petcare to Accelerate Leadership in Global Pet Tech Market|publisher=Yahoo Finance|date=2025-07-28|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

==~~Lawsuit~~==

==Consumer impact==

~~As of August 2025, no formal litigation has been filed regarding the~~ Whistle ~~shutdown~~. ~~Legal experts have identified potential claims under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act and state consumer protection statutes, though Tractive's free replacement program may affect damage calculations~~.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.~~webpronews~~.com/~~tractive~~-~~acquires~~-~~whistle~~-~~pet~~-~~trackers~~-~~obsolete~~-~~by-august-2025~~/|title=~~Tractive Acquires~~ Whistle: Pet ~~Trackers Obsolete by August 2025~~|publisher=~~WebProNews~~|date=2025-07-29|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

Both Whistle & Tractive devices require active subscriptions to function. The subscription fees cover cellular data costs necessary for GPS tracking.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.amazon.com/Whistle-100-00500-00-GPS-Pet-Tracker/dp/B015DV0O9C|title=Whistle GPS Pet Tracker|publisher=Amazon|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=https://tractive.com/en/c/plans|title=Tractive GPS Tracker Plans|publisher=Tractive|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref> Without an active subscription, neither device can perform location tracking or health monitoring functions.

~~The situation shares characteristics with~~ the ~~2016 Nest~~/~~Revolv case~~, ~~where~~ the ~~Federal Trade Commission reviewed but ultimately took no action after Google provided refunds~~ for ~~bricked smart home hubs~~.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.~~theregister~~.com/~~2016~~/07/15/~~ftc_lets_nest_off_hook_over_revolv~~/|title=~~FTC lets Nest off~~ the ~~hook over Revolv IoT hub bricking shame~~|publisher=The ~~Register~~|date=~~2016~~-07-15|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

===Subscription cost comparison===

Prior to the shutdown, Whistle subscription plans cost:

*Monthly: $9.95 per month

*Yearly: $8.25 per month when paid annually (approximately $99 per year)

*Some older plans: As low as $6.95 per month<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.chewy.com/whistle-3-dog-cat-gps-tracker/dp/138368|title=Whistle 3 Dog & Cat GPS Tracker|publisher=Chewy|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

Tractive subscription plans cost:

*Monthly: $10-12 per month (availability varies by country)

*Yearly: $5-9 per month when paid annually ($60-108 per year)

*Multi-year plans: As low as $5 per month<ref>{{cite web|url=https://tractive.com/en/c/plans|title=Tractive Subscription Plans|publisher=Tractive|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

'''Subscription costs are comparable.'''

===Non-financial consumer impacts===

Despite Tractive providing free replacement devices & similar subscription pricing, there are several areas of harm caused by the bricking of older devices:

'''Data loss''': All historical pet health data collected over years '''cannot be transferred to Tractive's platform''', affecting users who rely on this information for veterinary care decisions, particularly for pets with chronic conditions.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.whistle.com/blogs/news/whistle-joins-the-tractive-family|title=Whistle joins the Tractive Family|publisher=Whistle|date=2025-07-28|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

'''Feature reduction''': Whistle's specialized behavioral monitoring capabilities for tracking licking, scratching, and sleep quality are not available on Tractive devices, potentially affecting early detection of health issues.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.walmart.com/ip/Whistle-Go-Explore-Dog-GPS-Tracking-Device-and-Pet-Health-Monitoring-System-Grey-Fits-Most-Collars/2542522231|title=Whistle Go Explore Dog GPS Tracking Device|publisher=Walmart|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

'''Significantly reduced battery life''': Users report Whistle devices lasting 10-15 days per charge compared to Tractive's 2-7 days/.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.rover.com/blog/whistle-go-explore-review/|title=Whistle Go Explore Review|publisher=Rover|date=2024-09-03|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.dogster.com/lifestyle/tractive-dog-gps-tracker-review|title=Tractive Dog GPS Tracker 2025 Review|publisher=Dogster|date=2025-01-07|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

'''Accessory obsolescence''': All Whistle-specific hardware including chargers, collar attachments, & accessories become unusable, requiring additional replacement purchases beyond the tracker itself.

'''Inadequate transition period''': The 33-day notice period has been criticized as insufficient for users to research alternatives, claim replacements, & adapt to new systems, particularly affecting elderly users and households with multiple pets.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.engadget.com/wearables/whistle-pet-trackers-are-shutting-down-next-month-212828325.html|title=Whistle pet trackers are shutting down next month|publisher=Engadget|date=2025-07-30|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

'''Choice elimination''': The acquisition removes a major competitor from the pet tracking market, reducing consumer options & innovation pressure in the $100-150 price segment.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.webpronews.com/tractive-acquires-whistle-pet-trackers-obsolete-by-august-2025/|title=Tractive Acquires Whistle: Pet Trackers Obsolete by August 2025|publisher=WebProNews|date=2025-07-29|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

==Consumer response==

Consumer reactions have been documented across multiple platforms:

*Trustpilot reviews for Whistle average 2.4 out of 5 stars across 2,579 reviews, with recent complaints focusing on the shutdown announcement. <ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.trustpilot.com/review/whistle.com|title=Whistle Reviews|publisher=Trustpilot|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref> Reviews of the company & the product were consistently poor prior to the shutdown announcement.

*Better Business Bureau records show patterns of complaints regarding subscription issues and warranty concerns<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.bbb.org/us/ca/san-francisco/profile/find-a-pet/whistle-labs-1116-534049/complaints|title=Whistle Labs BBB Complaints|publisher=Better Business Bureau|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

*Reddit users have expressed frustration about losing years of pet health data when it comes to animals with medical conditions that require long-term monitoring<ref>{{cite web|url=https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/07/acquisition-sends-thousands-of-whistle-pet-trackers-to-iot-graveyard/|title=Acquisition sends thousands of Whistle pet trackers to IoT graveyard|publisher=Ars Technica|date=2025-07-29|author=Scharon Harding|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

One user stated that the loss of behavioral monitoring features was "very handy, so to lose that sucks" when describing how they used the device to track their dog's seasonal allergies.<ref>{{cite web |author= |date=2025-07-29 |title=Whistle question : r/tractivegps |url=https://www.reddit.com/r/tractivegps/comments/1mbflhn/comment/n5lwr0u/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1 |access-date=2025-08-12 |publisher=reddit}}</ref>

[[File:Reddit user discussing whistle device bricking.png|thumb|Whistle user discussing device bricking on Reddit <ref>{{Cite web |title= |url=https://www.reddit.com/r/tractivegps/comments/1mbflhn/comment/n5lwr0u/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button}}</ref>]]

Technology publication Engadget noted that "''thousands of GPS trackers and monitors will morph into e-waste in about a month."''<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.engadget.com/wearables/whistle-pet-trackers-are-shutting-down-next-month-212828325.html|title=Whistle pet trackers are shutting down next month|publisher=Engadget|date=2025-07-30|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

==~~Sadness~~==

==Institutional response==

The Whistle shutdown contributes to what the US PIRG Education Fund describes as an ''"Electronic Waste Graveyard"'' of over 100 tech products ~~that~~ have stopped working after manufacturers dropped support.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://pirg.org/edfund/resources/electronic-waste-graveyard/|title=Electronic Waste Graveyard|publisher=US PIRG Education Fund|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref> The organization estimates that expired software and canceled cloud services have created ''"a minimum of 130 million pounds of electronic waste"'' since 2014.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/07/acquisition-sends-thousands-of-whistle-pet-trackers-to-iot-graveyard/|title=Acquisition sends thousands of Whistle pet trackers to IoT graveyard|publisher=Ars Technica|date=2025-07-29|author=Scharon Harding|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

The Whistle shutdown contributes to what the US PIRG Education Fund describes as an ''"Electronic Waste Graveyard"'' of over 100 tech products, which have stopped working after manufacturers dropped support.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://pirg.org/edfund/resources/electronic-waste-graveyard/|title=Electronic Waste Graveyard|publisher=US PIRG Education Fund|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref> The organization estimates that expired software and canceled cloud services have created ''"a minimum of 130 million pounds of electronic waste"'' since 2014.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/07/acquisition-sends-thousands-of-whistle-pet-trackers-to-iot-graveyard/|title=Acquisition sends thousands of Whistle pet trackers to IoT graveyard|publisher=Ars Technica|date=2025-07-29|author=Scharon Harding|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

~~Similar incidents include:~~

==See also==

*Google's Nest bricking Revolv smart home hubs in 2016<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.pcworld.com/article/420413/why-nests-revolv-hubs-wont-be-the-last-iot-devices-knocked-offline.html|title=Why Nest's Revolv hubs won't be the last IoT devices knocked offline|publisher=PCWorld|date=2016-04-06|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

*Wink's 2020 demand for mandatory subscriptions with one week notice<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.consumerreports.org/smart-home/wink-tells-users-pay-up-or-we-will-disable-smart-home-hub/|title=Wink Tells Users: Pay $5 a Month or We'll Disable Your Smart Home Hub|publisher=Consumer Reports|date=2020-05-06|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

*[[Wink]]'s 2020 demand for mandatory subscriptions with one week notice<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.consumerreports.org/smart-home/wink-tells-users-pay-up-or-we-will-disable-smart-home-hub/|title=Wink Tells Users: Pay $5 a Month or We'll Disable Your Smart Home Hub|publisher=Consumer Reports|date=2020-05-06|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

*Best Buy's shutdown of Insignia smart home products in 2019<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.tomsguide.com/news/best-buy-is-dumbing-down-its-smart-home-devices|title=Best Buy Is Dumbing Down Its Smart Home Devices|publisher=Tom's Guide|date=2019-11-05|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

*[[Best Buy discontinuation of Insignia Connect|Best Buy's shutdown of Insignia smart home products]] in 2019<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.tomsguide.com/news/best-buy-is-dumbing-down-its-smart-home-devices|title=Best Buy Is Dumbing Down Its Smart Home Devices|publisher=Tom's Guide|date=2019-11-05|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>

==References==

@@ Line 40: / Line 40: @@
 Tractive CEO Michael Hurnaus characterized the acquisition as enabling the company to ''"deliver new features and improvements faster, more reliably, and with greater impact for all users—including former Whistle customers."''<ref>{{cite web|url=https://finance.yahoo.com/news/tractive-acquires-whistle-mars-petcare-110000346.html|title=Tractive Acquires Whistle from Mars Petcare to Accelerate Leadership in Global Pet Tech Market|publisher=Yahoo Finance|date=2025-07-28|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
-==Lawsuit==
+==Consumer impact==
-As of August 2025, no formal litigation has been filed regarding the Whistle shutdown. Legal experts have identified potential claims under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act and state consumer protection statutes, though Tractive's free replacement program may affect damage calculations.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.webpronews.com/tractive-acquires-whistle-pet-trackers-obsolete-by-august-2025/|title=Tractive Acquires Whistle: Pet Trackers Obsolete by August 2025|publisher=WebProNews|date=2025-07-29|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+Both Whistle & Tractive devices require active subscriptions to function. The subscription fees cover cellular data costs necessary for GPS tracking.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.amazon.com/Whistle-100-00500-00-GPS-Pet-Tracker/dp/B015DV0O9C|title=Whistle GPS Pet Tracker|publisher=Amazon|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=https://tractive.com/en/c/plans|title=Tractive GPS Tracker Plans|publisher=Tractive|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref> Without an active subscription, neither device can perform location tracking or health monitoring functions.
-The situation shares characteristics with the 2016 Nest/Revolv case, where the Federal Trade Commission reviewed but ultimately took no action after Google provided refunds for bricked smart home hubs.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.theregister.com/2016/07/15/ftc_lets_nest_off_hook_over_revolv/|title=FTC lets Nest off the hook over Revolv IoT hub bricking shame|publisher=The Register|date=2016-07-15|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+===Subscription cost comparison===
+Prior to the shutdown, Whistle subscription plans cost:
+*Monthly: $9.95 per month
+*Yearly: $8.25 per month when paid annually (approximately $99 per year)
+*Some older plans: As low as $6.95 per month<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.chewy.com/whistle-3-dog-cat-gps-tracker/dp/138368|title=Whistle 3 Dog & Cat GPS Tracker|publisher=Chewy|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+Tractive subscription plans cost:
+*Monthly: $10-12 per month (availability varies by country)
+*Yearly: $5-9 per month when paid annually ($60-108 per year)
+*Multi-year plans: As low as $5 per month<ref>{{cite web|url=https://tractive.com/en/c/plans|title=Tractive Subscription Plans|publisher=Tractive|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+'''Subscription costs are comparable.'''
+===Non-financial consumer impacts===
+Despite Tractive providing free replacement devices & similar subscription pricing, there are several areas of harm caused by the bricking of older devices:
+'''Data loss''': All historical pet health data collected over years '''cannot be transferred to Tractive's platform''', affecting users who rely on this information for veterinary care decisions, particularly for pets with chronic conditions.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.whistle.com/blogs/news/whistle-joins-the-tractive-family|title=Whistle joins the Tractive Family|publisher=Whistle|date=2025-07-28|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+'''Feature reduction''': Whistle's specialized behavioral monitoring capabilities for tracking licking, scratching, and sleep quality are not available on Tractive devices, potentially affecting early detection of health issues.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.walmart.com/ip/Whistle-Go-Explore-Dog-GPS-Tracking-Device-and-Pet-Health-Monitoring-System-Grey-Fits-Most-Collars/2542522231|title=Whistle Go Explore Dog GPS Tracking Device|publisher=Walmart|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+'''Significantly reduced battery life''': Users report Whistle devices lasting 10-15 days per charge compared to Tractive's 2-7 days/.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.rover.com/blog/whistle-go-explore-review/|title=Whistle Go Explore Review|publisher=Rover|date=2024-09-03|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.dogster.com/lifestyle/tractive-dog-gps-tracker-review|title=Tractive Dog GPS Tracker 2025 Review|publisher=Dogster|date=2025-01-07|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+'''Accessory obsolescence''': All Whistle-specific hardware including chargers, collar attachments, & accessories become unusable, requiring additional replacement purchases beyond the tracker itself.
+'''Inadequate transition period''': The 33-day notice period has been criticized as insufficient for users to research alternatives, claim replacements, & adapt to new systems, particularly affecting elderly users and households with multiple pets.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.engadget.com/wearables/whistle-pet-trackers-are-shutting-down-next-month-212828325.html|title=Whistle pet trackers are shutting down next month|publisher=Engadget|date=2025-07-30|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+'''Choice elimination''': The acquisition removes a major competitor from the pet tracking market, reducing consumer options & innovation pressure in the $100-150 price segment.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.webpronews.com/tractive-acquires-whistle-pet-trackers-obsolete-by-august-2025/|title=Tractive Acquires Whistle: Pet Trackers Obsolete by August 2025|publisher=WebProNews|date=2025-07-29|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
 ==Consumer response==
 Consumer reactions have been documented across multiple platforms:
 *Trustpilot reviews for Whistle average 2.4 out of 5 stars across 2,579 reviews, with recent complaints focusing on the shutdown announcement. <ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.trustpilot.com/review/whistle.com|title=Whistle Reviews|publisher=Trustpilot|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref> Reviews of the company & the product were consistently poor prior to the shutdown announcement.
 *Better Business Bureau records show patterns of complaints regarding subscription issues and warranty concerns<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.bbb.org/us/ca/san-francisco/profile/find-a-pet/whistle-labs-1116-534049/complaints|title=Whistle Labs BBB Complaints|publisher=Better Business Bureau|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
 *Reddit users have expressed frustration about losing years of pet health data when it comes to animals with medical conditions that require long-term monitoring<ref>{{cite web|url=https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/07/acquisition-sends-thousands-of-whistle-pet-trackers-to-iot-graveyard/|title=Acquisition sends thousands of Whistle pet trackers to IoT graveyard|publisher=Ars Technica|date=2025-07-29|author=Scharon Harding|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
 One user stated that the loss of behavioral monitoring features was "very handy, so to lose that sucks" when describing how they used the device to track their dog's seasonal allergies.<ref>{{cite web |author= |date=2025-07-29 |title=Whistle question : r/tractivegps |url=https://www.reddit.com/r/tractivegps/comments/1mbflhn/comment/n5lwr0u/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1 |access-date=2025-08-12 |publisher=reddit}}</ref>
+[[File:Reddit user discussing whistle device bricking.png|thumb|Whistle user discussing device bricking on Reddit <ref>{{Cite web |title= |url=https://www.reddit.com/r/tractivegps/comments/1mbflhn/comment/n5lwr0u/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button}}</ref>]]
 Technology publication Engadget noted that "''thousands of GPS trackers and monitors will morph into e-waste in about a month."''<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.engadget.com/wearables/whistle-pet-trackers-are-shutting-down-next-month-212828325.html|title=Whistle pet trackers are shutting down next month|publisher=Engadget|date=2025-07-30|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
-==Sadness==
+==Institutional response==
-The Whistle shutdown contributes to what the US PIRG Education Fund describes as an ''"Electronic Waste Graveyard"'' of over 100 tech products that have stopped working after manufacturers dropped support.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://pirg.org/edfund/resources/electronic-waste-graveyard/|title=Electronic Waste Graveyard|publisher=US PIRG Education Fund|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref> The organization estimates that expired software and canceled cloud services have created ''"a minimum of 130 million pounds of electronic waste"'' since 2014.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/07/acquisition-sends-thousands-of-whistle-pet-trackers-to-iot-graveyard/|title=Acquisition sends thousands of Whistle pet trackers to IoT graveyard|publisher=Ars Technica|date=2025-07-29|author=Scharon Harding|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+The Whistle shutdown contributes to what the US PIRG Education Fund describes as an ''"Electronic Waste Graveyard"'' of over 100 tech products, which have stopped working after manufacturers dropped support.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://pirg.org/edfund/resources/electronic-waste-graveyard/|title=Electronic Waste Graveyard|publisher=US PIRG Education Fund|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref> The organization estimates that expired software and canceled cloud services have created ''"a minimum of 130 million pounds of electronic waste"'' since 2014.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/07/acquisition-sends-thousands-of-whistle-pet-trackers-to-iot-graveyard/|title=Acquisition sends thousands of Whistle pet trackers to IoT graveyard|publisher=Ars Technica|date=2025-07-29|author=Scharon Harding|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
-Similar incidents include:
+==See also==
 *Google's Nest bricking Revolv smart home hubs in 2016<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.pcworld.com/article/420413/why-nests-revolv-hubs-wont-be-the-last-iot-devices-knocked-offline.html|title=Why Nest's Revolv hubs won't be the last IoT devices knocked offline|publisher=PCWorld|date=2016-04-06|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
-*Wink's 2020 demand for mandatory subscriptions with one week notice<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.consumerreports.org/smart-home/wink-tells-users-pay-up-or-we-will-disable-smart-home-hub/|title=Wink Tells Users: Pay $5 a Month or We'll Disable Your Smart Home Hub|publisher=Consumer Reports|date=2020-05-06|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+*[[Wink]]'s 2020 demand for mandatory subscriptions with one week notice<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.consumerreports.org/smart-home/wink-tells-users-pay-up-or-we-will-disable-smart-home-hub/|title=Wink Tells Users: Pay $5 a Month or We'll Disable Your Smart Home Hub|publisher=Consumer Reports|date=2020-05-06|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
-*Best Buy's shutdown of Insignia smart home products in 2019<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.tomsguide.com/news/best-buy-is-dumbing-down-its-smart-home-devices|title=Best Buy Is Dumbing Down Its Smart Home Devices|publisher=Tom's Guide|date=2019-11-05|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
+*[[Best Buy discontinuation of Insignia Connect|Best Buy's shutdown of Insignia smart home products]] in 2019<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.tomsguide.com/news/best-buy-is-dumbing-down-its-smart-home-devices|title=Best Buy Is Dumbing Down Its Smart Home Devices|publisher=Tom's Guide|date=2019-11-05|access-date=2025-08-12}}</ref>
 ==References==