Consumer Rights Wiki:Moderator guidelines: Difference between revisions

Kostas (talk | contribs)
m fix mistake - supress templates with nowiki
F. User provided insights:: edited and clarified some things.
Line 63: Line 63:
====A. Available tags:====
====A. Available tags:====
Articles which are substantially non-compliant with Wiki rules can (and should) be marked with the tags described below. The purposes of such flags are twofold:  
Articles which are substantially non-compliant with Wiki rules can (and should) be marked with the tags described below. The purposes of such flags are twofold:  
# to warn the reader of a potentially low-quality article, and  
#to warn the reader of a potentially low-quality article, and
# to bring such articles to the attention of admins and other editors, who may improve or remove the article.  
#to bring such articles to the attention of admins and other editors, who may improve or remove the article.
These tags can be used by writing <code><nowiki>{{TagName}}</nowiki></code> at the top of an article in the source editor. It is recommended to include a new line after the tag is added in order to make sure any future additions by users via the visual editor do not fall in the same line and causing problems with saving changes (as only wiki moderators can remove or add notices).  
These tags can be used by writing <code><nowiki>{{TagName}}</nowiki></code> at the top of an article in the source editor. It is recommended to include a new line after the tag is added in order to make sure any future additions by users via the visual editor do not fall in the same line and causing problems with saving changes (as only wiki moderators can remove or add notices).  
Adding tags via the visual editor is possible using the insert dialog but is not recommended as it can cause formatting or placement issues due to the lack of placement control.
Adding tags via the visual editor is possible using the insert dialog but is not recommended as it can cause formatting or placement issues due to the lack of placement control.


*[[Template:StubNotice|StubNotice]] <br/>Use for an article which is simply underdeveloped: the content currently within it does not justify its existence, but there is nothing wrong in concept with such an article existing in the wiki.
*[[Template:StubNotice|StubNotice]] <br />Use for an article which is simply underdeveloped: the content currently within it does not justify its existence, but there is nothing wrong in concept with such an article existing in the wiki.
*[[Template:Incomplete|Incomplete]] <br/>Use for an article that has the potential to be high-quality, but is dangerously under-cited, or the citations are to dubious sources. This should only lead to deletion if it's in violation of the No Original Reaearch policy, or if no good sources exist with which to fix it.
*[[Template:Incomplete|Incomplete]] <br />Use for an article that has the potential to be high-quality, but is dangerously under-cited, or the citations are to dubious sources. This should only lead to deletion if it's in violation of the No Original Reaearch policy, or if no good sources exist with which to fix it.
*[[Template:ToneWarning|ToneWarning]]<br/>Use for an article where the tone is significantly non-compliant, and needs major improvement
*[[Template:ToneWarning|ToneWarning]]<br />Use for an article where the tone is significantly non-compliant, and needs major improvement
*[[Template:Irrelevant|Irrelevant]] <br/>Use for an article that is on the edge of not being relevant, and an editor feels falls foul of the inclusion criteria above. Basically a limbo to put articles in where their merits can be discussed before a descision is made on their deletion.
*[[Template:Irrelevant|Irrelevant]] <br />Use for an article that is on the edge of not being relevant, and an editor feels falls foul of the inclusion criteria above. Basically a limbo to put articles in where their merits can be discussed before a descision is made on their deletion.
*[[Template:Garbage|Garbage]]<br/>Use for an article which is clearly irrelevant, spam, or not likely to be improved.
*[[Template:Garbage|Garbage]]<br />Use for an article which is clearly irrelevant, spam, or not likely to be improved.
*[[Template:SloppyAI|SloppyAI]]<br/>Use for an article where AI is heavily used without enough care and/or supervision to guarantee the credibility or readability or the article.
*[[Template:SloppyAI|SloppyAI]]<br />Use for an article where AI is heavily used without enough care and/or supervision to guarantee the credibility or readability or the article.


Optionally when using the <code>Incomplete</code> tag, up to four specific issues with the article can be pointed out by including <code><nowiki>Issue 1/2/3/4</nowiki></code> parameters these appear in a numbered list in the notice (see [[Template:Incomplete|Incomplete]] for example usage).
Optionally when using the <code>Incomplete</code> tag, up to four specific issues with the article can be pointed out by including <code><nowiki>Issue 1/2/3/4</nowiki></code> parameters these appear in a numbered list in the notice (see [[Template:Incomplete|Incomplete]] for example usage).
Line 84: Line 84:
!Umbrella category
!Umbrella category
|-
|-
| <code>StubNotice</code>
|<code>StubNotice</code>
|[[:Category:Articles requiring expansion|Articles requiring expansion]]
|[[:Category:Articles requiring expansion|Articles requiring expansion]]
|rowspan="3"| [[:Category:Articles in need of additional work |Aritcles in need of additional work]]
| rowspan="3" |[[:Category:Articles in need of additional work |Aritcles in need of additional work]]
|rowspan="6"| [[:Category:Todo|Todo]]
| rowspan="6" |[[:Category:Todo|Todo]]
|-
|-
| <code>Incomplete</code>
|<code>Incomplete</code>
| [[:Category:Articles with verification concerns or other deficiencies|Articles with verification concerns or other deficiencies]]
|[[:Category:Articles with verification concerns or other deficiencies|Articles with verification concerns or other deficiencies]]
|-
|-
| <code>ToneWarning</code>
|<code>ToneWarning</code>
| [[:Category:Articles requiring change in tone|Articles requiring change in tone]]
|[[:Category:Articles requiring change in tone|Articles requiring change in tone]]
|-
|-
| <code>Irrelevant</code>
|<code>Irrelevant</code>
|colspan="2"| [[:Category:Articles marked as irrelevant|Articles marked as irrelevant]]
| colspan="2" |[[:Category:Articles marked as irrelevant|Articles marked as irrelevant]]
|-
|-
| <code>Garbage</code>
|<code>Garbage</code>
|colspan="2"| [[:Category:Articles marked for deletion|Articles marked for deletion]]
| colspan="2" |[[:Category:Articles marked for deletion|Articles marked for deletion]]
|-
|-
| <code>SloppyAI</code>
|<code>SloppyAI</code>
|colspan="2"| [[:Category:Articles that heavily rely on AI|Articles that heavily rely on AI]]
| colspan="2" |[[:Category:Articles that heavily rely on AI|Articles that heavily rely on AI]]
|}
|}


Line 132: Line 132:
*The citing of sources for opinion or commentary should present a balanced and rational view, without giving undue weight to fringe opinions.
*The citing of sources for opinion or commentary should present a balanced and rational view, without giving undue weight to fringe opinions.


====F. User provided insights:====
====F. Deletion requests and merge requests:====
Users can use the request templates <code>DeletionRequest</code> ([[Template:DeletionRequest| deletion request template page]]) and <code>MergeRequest</code> [[Template:MergeRequest| merge request template page]]) to indicate pages that may need attention. Look through the [[:Category:Articles with merge requests|Articles with merge requests]] and [[:Category:Articles with deletion requests|Articles with deletion requests]] categories ( both in the [[:Category:Todo| todo]] category) in order to look though these requests.
Users can use the request templates <code>DeletionRequest</code> ([[Template:DeletionRequest|deletion request template page]]) and <code>MergeRequest</code>[[Template:MergeRequest| merge request template page]]) to indicate pages that may need attention. Look through the [[:Category:Articles with merge requests|Articles with merge requests]] and [[:Category:Articles with deletion requests|Articles with deletion requests]] categories (both in the[[:Category:Todo| todo]] category) in order to look though these requests.


If a deletion request is determined to be valid the linked pages need to be handled and after that the page should be marked with the <code><nowiki>{{Garbage}}</nowiki></code> temlpate and protected from edits pending final deletion.  
If a deletion request is determined to be valid the linked pages need to be handled and after that the page should be marked with the <code><nowiki>{{Garbage}}</nowiki></code> template and protected from edits, pending final deletion.  


In cases of merge requests once things might not pe as simple. After moving content to the page that is to be retained the page [[Special:MergeHistory]] should be used in order to maintain the edit history and contributors. This might become complicated if multiple pages are to be merged so going through them 2 at the time should probably be the way this is handles even if it results in some inefficiencies. After merging articles the redundant pages should be marked with the <code><nowiki>{{Garbage}}</nowiki></code> and protected from edits pending deletion.
In cases of merge requests, things might not be as simple. After deciding on the page which is to be kept, and moving all relevent content to that page, the page [[Special:MergeHistory]] should be used in order to maintain the edit history and contributors. This might become complicated if three or more pages are to be merged, so they should be merged sequentially to avoid conflicts. After merging, and ensuring the retention of all edit history, any redundant pages should be deleted.


==Example application of rules==
==Example application of rules==