Subscription service: Difference between revisions

Line 2:

A '''subscription service''' is an ongoing transaction agreement between the customer and the company, where a user usually pays on a weekly, monthly, or yearly basis to ~~use~~ the services provided by the company~~. In many cases, this model is used where a company has a sustained cost of doing business, some of which include cloud storage, VPN's and many other SaaS products~~.

A '''subscription service''' is an ongoing transaction agreement between the customer and the company, where a user usually pays on a weekly, monthly, or yearly basis to receive the services provided by the company.

==~~How it works~~==

== Traditional subscriptions ==

~~When an individual wishes to use~~ a ~~service like a VPN (Virtual Private Network) like Mulvad VPN,~~ an ~~ongoing payment agreement (subscription) is established so that the business~~ can ~~continue to~~ be ~~sustainable and profitable~~. ~~Prices may increase~~ or ~~decrease depending~~ on ~~various factors~~ and ~~promotions that~~ a ~~company may offer to attract more customers to experience their~~ service.

Traditionally this involves a physical act of an employee which can ''not'' be automated. Examples of this are companies or freelancers providing repeated gardening or cleaning jobs for consumers, or repeated mechanical maintenance for companies. Another type of traditional subscription is product-based services. These kinds of services repeatedly deliver physical products to a consumer, usually on a regular interval. This includes newspaper delivery and a meal-kit delivery service like HelloFresh.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}

==~~Why~~ is it a ~~problem?~~==

== Modern subscriptions ==

===Subscription-based economy ~~trend~~===

Subscription service revenue was estimated at "$3 trillion in 2024, up from estimates of around $2 trillion in 2023"<ref>[https://whop.com/blog/subscription-statistics/#:~:text=metrics%2C%20and%20more.-,Subscription%20Economy%20Statistics,%242%20trillion%20in%2020231. "100+ Subscription Statistics for 2025"] - whop.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20260210224358/https://whop.com/blog/subscription-statistics/ Archived])</ref>. Subscription services are becoming more prevalent. The replacement of permanent ownership with subscription services has some negative impacts that can harm consumer rights.

=== Automation ===

In the modern subscription landscape, the principal element of a subscription is ''automation.'' This isn't inherently anti-consumer, but it raises some concerns. A company can for example, regardless of consumer expectations, tweak values to exert direct control over the service. This means that unlike making a human gardener or cleaner intentionally degrade the quality of their work, it is ''really easy'' to degrade the quality of an automated service.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}

=== Digital medium ===

Modern subscriptions often provide a digital alternative to physical mediums, like DVDs, CDs, newspapers, and magazines. This isn't inherently anti-consumer, due to digital formats being more flexible. However, if using an [[Features on demand|on-demand]] business model, it requires [[activation]] with [[Forced cloud|forced-cloud]], usually enforced with [[digital rights management]], and this effectively gives up full ownership of the media to the service provider.

=== Anti-consumer signs ===

Signs to recognize anti-consumer subscriptions include:

# What the subscription provides are [[features on demand]] that are already built into the physical product.

# The subscription has multiple variants, usually called tiers, and if deployed with various [[Dark pattern|dark patterns]], create a [[fear of missing out]] in the consumer.

# When customer support is requested regarding the subscription, only an FAQ or chatbot is provided.

# The subscription provides the functionality that was previously free, a process known as [[enshittification]].

== Broader implications ==

===Subscription-based economy===

Subscription service revenue was estimated at "$3 trillion in 2024, up from estimates of around $2 trillion in 2023"<ref>[https://whop.com/blog/subscription-statistics/#:~:text=metrics%2C%20and%20more.-,Subscription%20Economy%20Statistics,%242%20trillion%20in%2020231. "100+ Subscription Statistics for 2025"] - whop.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20260210224358/https://whop.com/blog/subscription-statistics/ Archived])</ref>. Subscription services are becoming more prevalent. The replacement of permanent ownership with subscription services has some negative impacts that can harm consumer rights.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}

===Redefinition of ownership===

Instances of companies using the terms "ownership" and "own" when referring to subscription products and services have become prevalent. These instances are, at the bare minimum, misnomers: consumers do not own something if they have to pay a subscription to use it. The redefinition of language could be seen as a malicious attempt by companies to lessen the severity of the loss of ownership that consumers are now facing.

Instances of companies using the terms "ownership" and "own" when referring to subscription products and services have become prevalent. These instances are, at the bare minimum, misnomers: consumers do not own something if they have to pay a subscription to use it. The redefinition of language could be seen as a malicious attempt by companies to lessen the severity of the loss of ownership that consumers are now facing.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}

===OTA subscription paywall updates===

Companies like BMW paywall specific features on their cars that were once available without a subscription and advertised as a part of the original product that was purchased to get more money out of customers who may have bought the product for its feature lineup

Companies like BMW paywall specific features on their cars that were once available without a subscription and advertised as a part of the original product that was purchased to get more money out of customers who may have bought the product for its feature lineup.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}

===Making subscriptions hard to cancel===

Memberships and sign-ups, such as those for gyms, which offer a service, make it very easy to sign up online, and then, in turn, make it very hard to cancel. Specific gyms may even require you to certify that you are mailing them, just so that you can cancel the service you signed up for online. Additionally, some services like Adobe will even penalize you for canceling early instead of waiting for the subscription to expire and choosing not to renew. This practice is mainly designed to make consumers feel that it's not worth their time and effort to cancel the subscription.

Memberships and sign-ups, such as those for gyms, which offer a service, make it very easy to sign up online, and then, in turn, make it very hard to cancel. Specific gyms may even require you to certify that you are mailing them, just so that you can cancel the service you signed up for online. Additionally, some services like Adobe will even penalize you for canceling early instead of waiting for the subscription to expire and choosing not to renew. This practice is mainly designed to make consumers feel that it's not worth their time and effort to cancel the subscription.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}

===Licenses as subscriptions===

A [[license]] grants rights to use a product or service.<ref>[https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/licence "license"] - oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20250818080626/https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/licence Archived])</ref> Licenses differ from subscriptions in that they are permanent, whereas subscriptions are not. In addition, many companies choose to make temporary "licenses" last longer than subscriptions, as [[Adobe]] does.<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20250123232818/https://www.adobe.com/howtobuy/buying-programs.html "Adobe Buying Programs"] - archive.org - archived 2025-01-23 </ref> Licenses may also apply to large groups of people, e.g., a student license granted to students for free. The concern here is that [[License euthanasia|permanent licenses are being phased out]] using the [[retroactively amended purchase]] strategy, as [[Adobe Creative Suite activation#Removal of Adobe Lightroom perpetual licensing|Adobe has done]], possibly because subscriptions are more profitable. The term "license" is likely vulnerable to redefinition, as ownership is.

A [[license]] grants rights to use a product or service.<ref>[https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/licence "license"] - oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20250818080626/https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/licence Archived])</ref> Licenses differ from subscriptions in that they are permanent, whereas subscriptions are not. In addition, many companies choose to make temporary "licenses" last longer than subscriptions, as [[Adobe]] does.<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20250123232818/https://www.adobe.com/howtobuy/buying-programs.html "Adobe Buying Programs"] - archive.org - archived 2025-01-23 </ref> Licenses may also apply to large groups of people, e.g., a student license granted to students for free. The concern here is that [[License euthanasia|permanent licenses are being phased out]] using the [[retroactively amended purchase]] strategy, as [[Adobe Creative Suite activation#Removal of Adobe Lightroom perpetual licensing|Adobe has done]], possibly because subscriptions are more profitable. The term "license" is likely vulnerable to redefinition, as ownership is.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}

===Subscription inflation===

Subscription inflation occurs when companies increase subscription prices, often arbitrarily. This practice has been seen with Netflix subscriptions, where in 2025 "the standard monthly subscription without advertisements will climb from $15.49 to $17.99, and a standard monthly subscription with ads will increase one dollar to $7.99, Netflix said.<ref name=":0">[https://abcnews.go.com/Business/netflix-raises-prices-us-plans/story?id=117971949 "Netflix raises prices for all US plans. Here's what to know."] - abcnews.go.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20250722152022/https://abcnews.go.com/Business/netflix-raises-prices-us-plans/story?id=117971949 Archived])</ref> Subscription inflation need not be done to recoup lost revenue, as this Netflix subscription price increase actually occurred after a year of "a stellar earnings report" <ref name=":0" />, meaning that Netflix has the resources to improve its service without raising prices. Subscription inflation has been and will continue to be used solely to raise company profits by forcing consumers to pay more for what may be an inferior service.

Subscription inflation occurs when companies increase subscription prices, often arbitrarily. This practice has been seen with Netflix subscriptions, where in 2025 "the standard monthly subscription without advertisements will climb from $15.49 to $17.99, and a standard monthly subscription with ads will increase one dollar to $7.99, Netflix said.<ref name=":0">[https://abcnews.go.com/Business/netflix-raises-prices-us-plans/story?id=117971949 "Netflix raises prices for all US plans. Here's what to know."] - abcnews.go.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20250722152022/https://abcnews.go.com/Business/netflix-raises-prices-us-plans/story?id=117971949 Archived])</ref> Subscription inflation need not be done to recoup lost revenue, as this Netflix subscription price increase actually occurred after a year of "a stellar earnings report" <ref name=":0" />, meaning that Netflix has the resources to improve its service without raising prices. Subscription inflation has been and will continue to be used solely to raise company profits by forcing consumers to pay more for what may be an inferior service.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}

==Examples of ~~subscription services~~==

==Examples of modern subscriptions==

===TV/Film===

@@ Line 2: / Line 2: @@
 {{ToneWarning}}
-A '''subscription service''' is an ongoing transaction agreement between the customer and the company, where a user usually pays on a weekly, monthly, or yearly basis to use the services provided by the company. In many cases, this model is used where a company has a sustained cost of doing business, some of which include cloud storage, VPN's and many other SaaS products.
+A '''subscription service''' is an ongoing transaction agreement between the customer and the company, where a user usually pays on a weekly, monthly, or yearly basis to receive the services provided by the company.
-==How it works==
+== Traditional subscriptions ==
-When an individual wishes to use a service like a VPN (Virtual Private Network) like Mulvad VPN, an ongoing payment agreement (subscription) is established so that the business can continue to be sustainable and profitable. Prices may increase or decrease depending on various factors and promotions that a company may offer to attract more customers to experience their service.
+Traditionally this involves a physical act of an employee which can ''not'' be automated. Examples of this are companies or freelancers providing repeated gardening or cleaning jobs for consumers, or repeated mechanical maintenance for companies. Another type of traditional subscription is product-based services. These kinds of services repeatedly deliver physical products to a consumer, usually on a regular interval. This includes newspaper delivery and a meal-kit delivery service like HelloFresh.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}
-==Why is it a problem?==
+== Modern subscriptions ==
-===Subscription-based economy trend===
-Subscription service revenue was estimated at "$3 trillion in 2024, up from estimates of around $2 trillion in 2023"<ref>[https://whop.com/blog/subscription-statistics/#:~:text=metrics%2C%20and%20more.-,Subscription%20Economy%20Statistics,%242%20trillion%20in%2020231. "100+ Subscription Statistics for 2025"] - whop.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20260210224358/https://whop.com/blog/subscription-statistics/ Archived])</ref>. Subscription services are becoming more prevalent. The replacement of permanent ownership with subscription services has some negative impacts that can harm consumer rights.
+=== Automation ===
+In the modern subscription landscape, the principal element of a subscription is ''automation.'' This isn't inherently anti-consumer, but it raises some concerns. A company can for example, regardless of consumer expectations, tweak values to exert direct control over the service. This means that unlike making a human gardener or cleaner intentionally degrade the quality of their work, it is ''really easy'' to degrade the quality of an automated service.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}
+=== Digital medium ===
+Modern subscriptions often provide a digital alternative to physical mediums, like DVDs, CDs, newspapers, and magazines. This isn't inherently anti-consumer, due to digital formats being more flexible. However, if using an [[Features on demand|on-demand]] business model, it requires [[activation]] with [[Forced cloud|forced-cloud]], usually enforced with [[digital rights management]], and this effectively gives up full ownership of the media to the service provider.
+=== Anti-consumer signs ===
+Signs to recognize anti-consumer subscriptions include:
+# What the subscription provides are [[features on demand]] that are already built into the physical product.
+# The subscription has multiple variants, usually called tiers, and if deployed with various [[Dark pattern|dark patterns]], create a [[fear of missing out]] in the consumer.
+# When customer support is requested regarding the subscription, only an FAQ or chatbot is provided.
+# The subscription provides the functionality that was previously free, a process known as [[enshittification]].
+== Broader implications ==
+===Subscription-based economy===
+Subscription service revenue was estimated at "$3 trillion in 2024, up from estimates of around $2 trillion in 2023"<ref>[https://whop.com/blog/subscription-statistics/#:~:text=metrics%2C%20and%20more.-,Subscription%20Economy%20Statistics,%242%20trillion%20in%2020231. "100+ Subscription Statistics for 2025"] - whop.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20260210224358/https://whop.com/blog/subscription-statistics/ Archived])</ref>. Subscription services are becoming more prevalent. The replacement of permanent ownership with subscription services has some negative impacts that can harm consumer rights.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}
 ===Redefinition of ownership===
-Instances of companies using the terms "ownership" and "own" when referring to subscription products and services have become prevalent. These instances are, at the bare minimum, misnomers: consumers do not own something if they have to pay a subscription to use it. The redefinition of language could be seen as a malicious attempt by companies to lessen the severity of the loss of ownership that consumers are now facing.
+Instances of companies using the terms "ownership" and "own" when referring to subscription products and services have become prevalent. These instances are, at the bare minimum, misnomers: consumers do not own something if they have to pay a subscription to use it. The redefinition of language could be seen as a malicious attempt by companies to lessen the severity of the loss of ownership that consumers are now facing.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}
 ===OTA subscription paywall updates===
-Companies like BMW paywall specific features on their cars that were once available without a subscription and advertised as a part of the original product that was purchased to get more money out of customers who may have bought the product for its feature lineup
+Companies like BMW paywall specific features on their cars that were once available without a subscription and advertised as a part of the original product that was purchased to get more money out of customers who may have bought the product for its feature lineup.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}
 ===Making subscriptions hard to cancel===
-Memberships and sign-ups, such as those for gyms, which offer a service, make it very easy to sign up online, and then, in turn, make it very hard to cancel. Specific gyms may even require you to certify that you are mailing them, just so that you can cancel the service you signed up for online. Additionally, some services like Adobe will even penalize you for canceling early instead of waiting for the subscription to expire and choosing not to renew. This practice is mainly designed to make consumers feel that it's not worth their time and effort to cancel the subscription.
+Memberships and sign-ups, such as those for gyms, which offer a service, make it very easy to sign up online, and then, in turn, make it very hard to cancel. Specific gyms may even require you to certify that you are mailing them, just so that you can cancel the service you signed up for online. Additionally, some services like Adobe will even penalize you for canceling early instead of waiting for the subscription to expire and choosing not to renew. This practice is mainly designed to make consumers feel that it's not worth their time and effort to cancel the subscription.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}
 ===Licenses as subscriptions===
-A [[license]] grants rights to use a product or service.<ref>[https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/licence "license"] - oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20250818080626/https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/licence Archived])</ref> Licenses differ from subscriptions in that they are permanent, whereas subscriptions are not. In addition, many companies choose to make temporary "licenses" last longer than subscriptions, as [[Adobe]] does.<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20250123232818/https://www.adobe.com/howtobuy/buying-programs.html "Adobe Buying Programs"] - archive.org - archived 2025-01-23 </ref> Licenses may also apply to large groups of people, e.g., a student license granted to students for free. The concern here is that [[License euthanasia|permanent licenses are being phased out]] using the [[retroactively amended purchase]] strategy, as [[Adobe Creative Suite activation#Removal of Adobe Lightroom perpetual licensing|Adobe has done]], possibly because subscriptions are more profitable. The term "license" is likely vulnerable to redefinition, as ownership is.
+A [[license]] grants rights to use a product or service.<ref>[https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/licence "license"] - oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20250818080626/https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/licence Archived])</ref> Licenses differ from subscriptions in that they are permanent, whereas subscriptions are not. In addition, many companies choose to make temporary "licenses" last longer than subscriptions, as [[Adobe]] does.<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20250123232818/https://www.adobe.com/howtobuy/buying-programs.html "Adobe Buying Programs"] - archive.org - archived 2025-01-23 </ref> Licenses may also apply to large groups of people, e.g., a student license granted to students for free. The concern here is that [[License euthanasia|permanent licenses are being phased out]] using the [[retroactively amended purchase]] strategy, as [[Adobe Creative Suite activation#Removal of Adobe Lightroom perpetual licensing|Adobe has done]], possibly because subscriptions are more profitable. The term "license" is likely vulnerable to redefinition, as ownership is.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}
 ===Subscription inflation===
-Subscription inflation occurs when companies increase subscription prices, often arbitrarily. This practice has been seen with Netflix subscriptions, where in 2025 "the standard monthly subscription without advertisements will climb from $15.49 to $17.99, and a standard monthly subscription with ads will increase one dollar to $7.99, Netflix said.<ref name=":0">[https://abcnews.go.com/Business/netflix-raises-prices-us-plans/story?id=117971949 "Netflix raises prices for all US plans. Here's what to know."] - abcnews.go.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20250722152022/https://abcnews.go.com/Business/netflix-raises-prices-us-plans/story?id=117971949 Archived])</ref> Subscription inflation need not be done to recoup lost revenue, as this Netflix subscription price increase actually occurred after a year of "a stellar earnings report" <ref name=":0" />, meaning that Netflix has the resources to improve its service without raising prices. Subscription inflation has been and will continue to be used solely to raise company profits by forcing consumers to pay more for what may be an inferior service.
+Subscription inflation occurs when companies increase subscription prices, often arbitrarily. This practice has been seen with Netflix subscriptions, where in 2025 "the standard monthly subscription without advertisements will climb from $15.49 to $17.99, and a standard monthly subscription with ads will increase one dollar to $7.99, Netflix said.<ref name=":0">[https://abcnews.go.com/Business/netflix-raises-prices-us-plans/story?id=117971949 "Netflix raises prices for all US plans. Here's what to know."] - abcnews.go.com - accessed 2025-01-23 ([http://web.archive.org/web/20250722152022/https://abcnews.go.com/Business/netflix-raises-prices-us-plans/story?id=117971949 Archived])</ref> Subscription inflation need not be done to recoup lost revenue, as this Netflix subscription price increase actually occurred after a year of "a stellar earnings report" <ref name=":0" />, meaning that Netflix has the resources to improve its service without raising prices. Subscription inflation has been and will continue to be used solely to raise company profits by forcing consumers to pay more for what may be an inferior service.{{Citation needed|reason=1 Apr 2026}}
-==Examples of subscription services==
+==Examples of modern subscriptions==
 ===TV/Film===