Renault UK End EV Battery Lease Agreement: Difference between revisions

Fitzy89 (talk | contribs)
Formatting
m Hyperlinked to class action lawsuit.
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit Visual edit
 
Line 18: Line 18:
*'''Battery Lease Background:'''
*'''Battery Lease Background:'''


** New electric cars no longer come with battery leases.
**New electric cars no longer come with battery leases.
** Battery leases were primarily available on Renault Zoe models (up to 2019) and early Nissan Leaf models.
**Battery leases were primarily available on Renault Zoe models (up to 2019) and early Nissan Leaf models.
** Renault's battery lease was managed by RCI Bank, now known as Mobilize.
**Renault's battery lease was managed by RCI Bank, now known as Mobilize.


*'''Battery Lease Terms:'''
*'''Battery Lease Terms:'''
** Lease agreements require a minimum term (usually 1–3 years).
**Lease agreements require a minimum term (usually 1–3 years).
** After the minimum term, the lease can be terminated with one month’s written notice.
**After the minimum term, the lease can be terminated with one month’s written notice.
** The agreement mentions responsibility for battery removal and restocking fees but lacks clear details about additional costs.
**The agreement mentions responsibility for battery removal and restocking fees but lacks clear details about additional costs.


*'''Challenges with Lease Termination:'''
*'''Challenges with Lease Termination:'''


** '''''Process Issues:''''' The speaker faces difficulties even initiating the return process, as local Renault dealerships are unaware of the procedure, and Mobilize relies on these third parties without clear contractual obligations.
**'''''Process Issues:''''' The speaker faces difficulties even initiating the return process, as local Renault dealerships are unaware of the procedure, and Mobilize relies on these third parties without clear contractual obligations.
** '''''Excessive Fees:''''' If the process progresses, removal costs are estimated around £450, with additional transport costs to France pushing the total to approximately £1,400.
**'''''Excessive Fees:''''' If the process progresses, removal costs are estimated around £450, with additional transport costs to France pushing the total to approximately £1,400.
** '''''Legal Concerns:''''' The speaker argues that these transport fees are not explicitly mentioned in the lease agreement and are therefore unreasonable.
**'''''Legal Concerns:''''' The speaker argues that these transport fees are not explicitly mentioned in the lease agreement and are therefore unreasonable.


*'''Legal Action Initiated:'''
*'''Legal Action Initiated:'''


** A "Letter Before Action" has been sent to Renault, citing failure to fulfil contractual obligations, effectively trapping the speaker in a contract without a viable exit.
**A "Letter Before Action" has been sent to Renault, citing failure to fulfil contractual obligations, effectively trapping the speaker in a contract without a viable exit.
** The speaker plans to pursue a "small claims court" case, seeking the battery’s buyout cost (£253.20) as a legal strategy to terminate the lease.
**The speaker plans to pursue a "small claims court" case, seeking the battery’s buyout cost (£253.20) as a legal strategy to terminate the lease.
** ''Frustration of Contract:'' The speaker references the legal concept of "frustration of contract," where a party cannot fulfil their contractual obligations due to circumstances beyond their control.
**''Frustration of Contract:'' The speaker references the legal concept of "frustration of contract," where a party cannot fulfil their contractual obligations due to circumstances beyond their control.


*'''Wider Consumer Impact:'''
*'''Wider Consumer Impact:'''


** The speaker has created a Google Form to collect data from others affected by battery lease issues, aiming to identify patterns of unfair practices.
**The speaker has created a Google Form to collect data from others affected by battery lease issues, aiming to identify patterns of unfair practices.
** Reports from viewers reveal widespread problems, including:
**Reports from viewers reveal widespread problems, including:
** Inability to return leased batteries due to dealership incompetence or indifference.
**Inability to return leased batteries due to dealership incompetence or indifference.
** Cases of insurance write-offs where battery leases remain active, as insurers failed to settle the lease.
**Cases of insurance write-offs where battery leases remain active, as insurers failed to settle the lease.
** Consumers paying excessive fees to terminate leases or being forced to buy out batteries at inflated prices.
**Consumers paying excessive fees to terminate leases or being forced to buy out batteries at inflated prices.


*'''Potential Class Action:'''
*'''Potential Class Action:'''


** If a significant number of affected consumers come forward, the speaker suggests exploring broader legal action, possibly a class action lawsuit, to challenge Mobilize and Renault's practices.
**If a significant number of affected consumers come forward, the speaker suggests exploring broader legal action, possibly a [[class action lawsuit]], to challenge Mobilize and Renault's practices.


*'''Options for Ending the Lease:'''
*'''Options for Ending the Lease:'''


** '''''Buying out the battery:''''' Costs around £2,000, despite the market value being significantly lower (~£500).
**'''''Buying out the battery:''''' Costs around £2,000, despite the market value being significantly lower (~£500).
** '''''Paying removal and transport fees:''''' Approximately £1,400, viewed as excessive and potentially unenforceable.
**'''''Paying removal and transport fees:''''' Approximately £1,400, viewed as excessive and potentially unenforceable.
** '''''Legal action:''''' Using small claims court to dispute fees and force lease termination.
**'''''Legal action:''''' Using small claims court to dispute fees and force lease termination.


*'''Additional Issues:'''
*'''Additional Issues:'''


** '''''Resale Complications:''''' Difficulty transferring leases during car sales due to complex paperwork and delays from the finance company.
**'''''Resale Complications:''''' Difficulty transferring leases during car sales due to complex paperwork and delays from the finance company.
** '''''Insurance Write-offs:''''' Cases where vehicles declared as write-offs still carry active battery leases, as insurance companies fail to settle outstanding agreements properly.
**'''''Insurance Write-offs:''''' Cases where vehicles declared as write-offs still carry active battery leases, as insurance companies fail to settle outstanding agreements properly.
** '''''Potential Credit Risks:''''' Cancelling direct debits to end payments could harm credit ratings, even if legally justified.
**'''''Potential Credit Risks:''''' Cancelling direct debits to end payments could harm credit ratings, even if legally justified.
** '''''Remote Disabling:''''' Renault reserves the right to disable the vehicle’s charging capability via telematics if lease payments are missed, provided the telematics system is functional.
**'''''Remote Disabling:''''' Renault reserves the right to disable the vehicle’s charging capability via telematics if lease payments are missed, provided the telematics system is functional.


===Conclusion===
===Conclusion===