Jump to content

Self-destructive design

From Consumer_Action_Taskforce
Revision as of 17:01, 28 January 2025 by Jack Andersen (talk | contribs) (Introduce Self-destructive design page for the eventual unification of PO, DB, EOL, etc.)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

Self-destructive design is a generic form of product design whereby it is possible that some if not all functions of the device will cease functioning. Self-destructive design can occur unintentionally due to oversights but it can be implemented intentionally for a number of reasons. Self-destructive design is split into numerous types: discontinuation bricking, end-of-life irreparability, and planned obsolescence. All forms of self-destructive design harm consumers in that it reduces product lifetime and increases waste production.

Overall impacts

All types of self-destructive design share common impacts on consumer rights.

Actively malicious behavior

All types of self-destructive design can occur out of malicious intent to ruin a consumer's product but it is important to note that only planned obsolescence is always malicious in that it is the only one that has a direct intent to reduce product functionality.

Excessive waste

Excessive waste of all forms are inevitable in all types of self-destructive design. The loss of product or component functionality will create justification for consumers to discard their product and replace it with a functioning one; in fact planned obsolescence is often implemented with this intent.

Hard vs soft bricking

The term "bricking" refers to the process of a product losing functionality to the point that it becomes "brick-like" -- just a useless object. A product becomes hard-bricked if all its functionality is lost, usually in a very sudden manner -- in the flick of a switch. Hard-bricked devices are often difficult to de-brick. A product becomes soft-bricked when some of its functionality is lost. Soft-bricking can occur quickly but it can also slowly progress into hard-bricking; I.E: oxidation of a processor slowly killing it.

Dependence on third-parties

Some consumers will wish to repair their products after it has been damaged.

Type | Impact Actively malicious behavior Excessive waste Soft-brick Hard-brick
Planned Obsolescence Always Guaranteed Likely Possible but unlikely as of now
Discontinuation Bricking Sometimes Guaranteed Unlikely Often
EOL Irreparability Sometimes Guaranteed Likely Likely

Planned obsolescence

Discontinuation bricking

Digital bricking

End-of-life irreparability