Jump to content

User:Louis/Forced installation of Flock cameras in Denver, Colorado

From Consumer Rights Wiki

Forced installation of Flock cameras in Denver, Colorado began with the Denver City Council's rejection of a two-year Flock surveillance-camera contract on May 5, 2025,[1] and continued through a series of mayoral extensions that kept the cameras running until the city's Flock contract expired on March 31, 2026, when Denver decommissioned and removed all 110 of the city's Flock cameras.[2]

WHAT HAPPENED

[edit | edit source]

On May 5, 2025, the Denver City Council rejected a $666,000 two-year extension for Flock ALPR cameras with a vote of 12-0.[3] 63 days later, in July 2025, Mayor Mike Johnston signed a $498,500 contract with Flock which is $1,500 under the $500k approval threshold, keeping the cameras running through October 31, 2025. That maneuver and date range are documented by Axios[4] and the ACLU of Colorado.[5]

The second bypass, contract expiration, and the April 2026 lapse

[edit | edit source]

The July 2025 contract kept the cameras running through October 31, 2025. On October 22, 2025, Mayor Johnston bypassed the City Council a second time, extending the Flock contract by another five months at no cost, which meant council did not have to approve it, and ran the contract through March 31, 2026.[6]

The Flock contract expired on March 31, 2026. The same day, the City Council voted 7 to 6 to approve a one-year, $150,000 contract with Axon for 50 cameras, with Council President Amanda Sandoval among the seven yes-votes, and Denver decommissioned and removed all 110 of the city's Flock cameras.[7][2][8] Council member Serena Gonzales-Gutierrez, who has pushed to end the program, voted against the Axon contract.[7] The 50 Axon cameras would be installed in the coming weeks, and the ACLU of Colorado reported that the replacement system would not be operational for several weeks, so the city-run ALPR network was offline through April 2026, though private Flock cameras remained in operation throughout Denver.[7][9]

What happened to auto theft

[edit | edit source]

Denver Police Department data obtained by 9NEWS through a public-records request showed motor vehicle theft fell from 439 in April 2025, when the cameras were on, to 313 in April 2026, when the city's Flock network was offline, a 29% decrease, while auto-theft cases cleared by arrest dropped from 13% to 3%.[10] A query of Denver's Open Data crime feature service pulled June 14, 2026 returned slightly lower totals for the same two months, about 430 and about 301, because that dataset is revised continuously after the fact. The portal's documentation states the data is dynamic, which allows for additions, deletions and/or modifications at any time as reports are reclassified or removed during investigation, so a later pull reads lower than a one-time records-request snapshot.[11][12] This is a single month with a small sample, so it cannot by itself establish that the cameras made no difference.

The Denver Open Data crime dataset, the Denver Police NIBRS offense records the article queried for the April auto-theft counts.[11]

The Colorado Auto Theft Prevention Authority's Cale Gould has attributed the statewide auto-theft decline to a combination of factors rather than cameras alone, telling the Denver Gazette it wasn't one thing that changed, but collectively everything, and crediting 2023 changes to Colorado law such as Senate Bill 23-097.[13] Senate Bill 23-097, titled Motor Vehicle Theft and Unauthorized Use, was signed June 2, 2023 and took effect July 1, 2023. It rewrote Colorado's motor vehicle theft statute, C.R.S. 18-4-409, to drop the previous penalty grading by the stolen vehicle's value and instead grade the offense by the offender's conduct and record, so that motor vehicle theft is charged as a felony regardless of the car's worth, and it created a separate lesser offense of unauthorized use of a motor vehicle at C.R.S. 18-4-409.5.[14][15]

The Denver Gazette quoted Cale Gould of the state auto theft authority saying it wasn't one thing that changed, but collectively everything, crediting several factors for the decline.[13]

The Hyundai and Kia theft wave

[edit | edit source]

Hyundai and Kia vehicles built without engine immobilizers were a major target of auto theft during this period. Many 2011 to 2022 Hyundai and 2011 to 2021 Kia models shipped without that anti-theft feature, and a method to start them spread on social media; the Highway Loss Data Institute recorded a roughly tenfold rise in theft-claim frequency for those vehicles between 2020 and 2023.[16] On February 14, 2023, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration announced a free anti-theft software upgrade for about 3.8 million Hyundai and 4.5 million Kia vehicles.[17] Colorado tracks its thefts by make: the Colorado Auto Theft Prevention Authority reported that Hyundai and Kia vehicles were 25% of all vehicles stolen statewide in 2022,[18] a share that fell to 15%, or 2,445 of 16,291 stolen vehicles, in 2025, with the Hyundai Elantra and Sonata among the most stolen vehicles in the state.[19] Statewide, Colorado auto theft fell 25% in 2024[18] and 34% in 2025,[19] a decline that overlapped both the manufacturers' software fix and Senate Bill 23-097. These are statewide figures by make and year, not a Denver monthly breakdown.


What the law says:

[edit | edit source]

Denver Charter and City procurement rules:

[edit | edit source]

City Council must approve contracts over $500,000 according to Charter § 3.2.6[20]. This is Page 58, section E:

(E) Approval of certain contracts by Council. Contracts which will require or result in the payment or receipt by the City of one-half million dollars ($500,000.00) or more, and those in which personal property valued at one-half million dollars ($500,000.00) or more will be sold or transferred by or to the City, and those in which a provider of services to the City will receive a percentage of generated revenues, shall require the approval of the City Council acting by ordinance or resolution, prior to their execution by City officials

Also refer to Denver's $500,000 City Council approval rule, memorandum 8A[21]. This is Page 15, section H City Council, #1, item a, subsection 1:

Contracts that may require the City to expend $500,000 or more or sell personal property worth $500,000 or more, and amendments which cause the total contract to exceed that amount

The contract was for $498,500, not $500,000. However, the Denver Purchasing Manual says the following on page 13:[22]

Buyers shall be diligent in preventing agency avoidance of the formal or informal bid thresholds or City Council required ordinance thresholds by artificially dividing requisitions to avoid any procurement regulations described in Article 20-64 of the Revised Municipal Code.

Colorado statutes

[edit | edit source]
  • C.R.S. § 18-8-404[23], First-degree official misconduct: a public servant commits misconduct if, with intent to obtain a benefit, they violate any statute or lawfully adopted rule relating to their office (Class 1 misdemeanor)
What's a "benefit"?
[edit | edit source]

A benefit isn't just a bag of cash under the table.

The definition of "benefit" is found in Colorado Revised Statutes § 18-1-901(3)(b)[24],

(b) Benefit means any gain or advantage to the beneficiary including any gain or advantage to another person pursuant to the desire or consent of the beneficiary.

Section 18-1-901 contains general definitions that apply throughout Title 18 (Colorado Criminal Code), including the offenses in Article 8 (Governmental Operations).

The definition is broad and includes:

  1. Any gain or advantage, which is not limited to money or personal enrichment
  2. Benefits to other people if the defendant wanted them to benefit
  3. Policy outcomes, getting a governmental result the mayor wants
  4. Avoiding negative consequences like bypassing rejection

This is way broader than personal financial enrichment. If Mayor Johnston saw getting the Flock contract approved as advantageous, that qualifies as a benefit.


Case Law: People v. Luttrell
[edit | edit source]

People v. Luttrell, 636 P.2d 712 (Colo. 1981)[25]

Intent to commit embezzlement of public property, official misconduct, and theft may be inferred from the defendants' conduct and the circumstances of the case.[25]

Direct evidence such as an email from the mayor saying "I'm doing this to avoid council approval" might not be necessary. It could be possible to prove criminal intent by inferring via the existing details.

  • The timing of actions, 63 days after 12-0 vote rejecting Flock contract
  • The specificity of the contract amount, which is 0.3% under the legal limit
  • Surrounding circumstances, same vendor and same service, just repriced
This doesn't have to be a bribe; read "pecuniary benefit"
[edit | edit source]

For comparison, Colorado law distinguishes between benefit and pecuniary benefit.

C.R.S. § 18-1-901(3)(m) Pecuniary benefit means benefit in the form of money, property, commercial interests, or anything else, the primary significance of which is economic gain.[26]

The statute uses "pecuniary benefit" when it means financial enrichment specifically. The fact that § 18-8-404 uses just "benefit" (not "pecuniary benefit") proves our point that the legislature wanted a broader meaning of the word "benefit" in this context.

How it can apply to the mayor
[edit | edit source]

Under the verified statutory definition, a mayor obtains a "benefit" by:

  1. policy benefit: he implemented his surveillance camera policy that he believed is necessary
  2. political benefit: avoided the political cost of removing operational cameras
  3. institutional benefit: expanding executive authority over public safety
  4. 3rd benefit: Flock keeps getting Denver taxpayer money without consent

NONE OF THIS REQUIRES PERSONAL FINANCIAL ENRICHMENT TO BE AGAINST THE LAW! The "gain or advantage" is getting the contract approved after City Council rejected it.

WHAT YOU NEED TO DO!

[edit | edit source]

We have to make it legally and politically untenable for the mayor to continue with his actions to extend the Flock contract past October 31st 2025. Help with the following:

1) File complaints

[edit | edit source]

Attorney General complaint

[edit | edit source]
  • Click here to file a complaint with the Colorado Attorney General (Phil Weiser). Choose Deprivation of Rights by a Governmental Authority: Allege contract-splitting to evade oversight (C.R.S. § 31-15-712[27]) and official misconduct (C.R.S. § 18-8-404), citing:
    • The Council's 12-0 rejection of the $666,000 extension on May 5[28]
    • The $498,500 deal in July (exactly $1,500 under the threshold) and intent to evade Council
    • 1,400+ ICE searches of Denver data[29] and potential conflict with state limits on sharing PII to aid immigration enforcement[30]

WHAT TO SAY:

I am filing a formal complaint regarding Mayor Mike Johnston's violations of Colorado law. On May 5, 2025, Denver City Council unanimously rejected a Flock Safety camera contract, 12 no to 0 yes. 63 days later, Mayor Johnston signed a $498,500 contract with Flock which is exactly $1,500 below the $500,000 threshold requiring council approval under Denver Charter § 3.2.6.

This appears to be deliberate circumvention of required legislative oversight, violating C.R.S. § 18-8-404 (Official Misconduct). Additionally, this artificial division of a contract to evade approval requirements violates the Denver Purchasing Manual says the following on page 13:

Buyers shall be diligent in preventing agency avoidance of the formal or informal bid thresholds or City Council required ordinance thresholds by artificially dividing requisitions to avoid any procurement regulations described in Article 20-64 of the Revised Municipal Code.

Under C.R.S. § 18-1-901(3)(b), benefit means any gain or advantage to the beneficiary including any gain or advantage to another person pursuant to the desire or consent of the beneficiary.

Mayor Johnston obtained a benefit by successfully implementing a surveillance contract that city council had unanimously rejected 63 days earlier. Under People v. Luttrell, 636 P.2d 712 (Colo. 1981), intent can be inferred from conduct and circumstances. The precise pricing ($498,500, which is 0.3% below the $500,000 threshold) and timing (immediately after rejection) demonstrate knowing violation with intent to obtain the benefit of contract approval.

I respectfully request your office:

  1. Investigate whether Mayor Johnston violated C.R.S. § 18-1-901(3)(b) and C.R.S. § 18-8-404
  2. Subpoena internal communications between the Mayor's office and Flock Safety regarding contract pricing and structuring
  3. Review whether the Mayor's office discussed the $500,000 threshold when structuring this deal
  4. Charge Mayor Johnston if the evidence supports criminal violations

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

Denver District Attorney complaint

[edit | edit source]
  • Submit directly to the Denver District Attorney alongside the AG filing.
  • Use the same "What to say" text above, tailored to request a criminal inquiry into official misconduct and threshold avoidance, and include your attachments.

2) Denver Code of Ethics; DRMC §§ 2-51 (letter and spirit)

[edit | edit source]

The code requires acting within the letter and spirit of ethics rules and avoiding even the appearance of impropriety.[31] Alleged end-run behavior can be challenged as violating § 2-51's intent.

Click to file a complaint with the Denver Board of Ethics: claim misuse of office by the mayor by circumventing Charter § 3.2.6 and violating the City Purchasing Manual (ban on artificially dividing to avoid Council review, manual p.13).

3) SIGN UP TO SPEAK AT CITY COUNCIL GENERAL PUBLIC COMMENTS, IMMEDIATELY

[edit | edit source]

Tell the City Council on the record that you want this investigated, as they can pressure the district attorney. Sign up for the Monday General Public Comment which takes place at 5 PM, October 20th, 2025. Do it before 2 PM the day of.

Ask City Council to refer this matter to the auditor and district attorney, and to schedule an oversight hearing. CLICK HERE FOR INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO SIGN UP!

Ask City Council to introduce a pre-deadline resolution declaring any unilateral extension improper and demanding Council review for any surveillance-tech contract (example of this, New Orleans' tightening of oversight after a mayoral end-run)[32].

4) FILE COLORADO OPEN RECORDS ACT REQUESTS

[edit | edit source]

While statements have been made by City Council members discussing the contract's improper extension, we're going to want the hard documents. That requires a request.

How to Make a Colorado Open Records Request

[edit | edit source]
Step 1: visit the portal
[edit | edit source]

Go to: https://www.denvergov.org/openrecords

Step 2: what departments to get records from
[edit | edit source]

Submit SEPARATE requests to each department (increases chances of getting documents):

Mayor's Office
[edit | edit source]
  • Department: Office of the Mayor
  • Records Custodian: Mayor's Office Communications
  • Request:
    • All contracts with Flock Safety executed July 2025
    • All emails between Mayor's Office and Flock Safety (April 1 - July 31, 2025)
    • All internal emails containing "Flock" AND "$500,000" or "threshold"
    • Meeting calendars showing any Flock Safety meetings
City Attorney's Office
[edit | edit source]
  • Department: Denver City Attorney's Office
  • Records Custodian: Legal Department
  • Request:
    • Legal review memos for Flock contract
    • Emails regarding "contract structuring" or "council approval threshold"
    • Any legal opinions on contracts under $500,000
Department of Finance
[edit | edit source]
  • Department: Department of Finance
  • Records Custodian: Controller's Office
  • Request:
    • Purchase orders for Flock Safety
    • Budget documents showing the $498,500 allocation
    • Any procurement waivers or exemptions filed
Denver City Council
[edit | edit source]
  • Department: Denver City Council
  • Records Custodian: Council Secretary
  • Request:
    • Complete minutes and vote record from May 5, 2025 meeting
    • All council communications regarding Flock rejection
    • Any subsequent communications from Mayor's office about Flock
Step 3: what to say
[edit | edit source]

some ideas:

"This request includes all responsive records in any format including:

  • Emails (including attachments)
  • Text messages
  • Teams/Slack/Official work chat messages
  • Handwritten notes
  • Calendar entries
  • Phone logs
  • Draft documents

Search terms should include variations like:

  • 'Flock' OR 'ALPR' OR 'license plate reader'
  • '$498' OR '$499' OR 'four hundred ninety'
  • 'threshold' OR 'limit' OR 'approval requirement'

Time period: April 1, 2025 through July 31, 2025"

Step 4: save yourself money
[edit | edit source]

Add this to avoid fees:

"I request a fee waiver as this information is in the public interest regarding potential circumvention of City Council authority. Disclosure will contribute significantly to public understanding of government operations."

Step 5: documents to focus on
[edit | edit source]
  1. Contract Modification
    • Original $666,000 contract draft
    • Revised $498,500 or $499,000 contract
    • Change orders or amendments
  2. Keep-It-Under Emails
    • Search: "under 500" "below threshold" "avoid council"
    • Any email sent between May 6-July 6, 2025
  3. The Timeline Documents
    • May 5 council rejection documentation
    • July 7 contract execution
    • Any June communications showing planning
Step 6: Follow-up
[edit | edit source]
  • Should get acknowledgement in 1-3 days
  • 7 days for "extenuating circumstances"
  • After 10 days, file a complaint if you get no response
Sample Request Text
[edit | edit source]

Under the Colorado Open Records Act § 24-72-201 et seq., I request access to the following records:

All communications, contracts, and documents related to agreements with Flock Safety or regarding automated license plate readers (ALPR) between April 1, 2025 and July 31, 2025, specifically including:

  1. The executed contract for $498,500 signed in July 2025 according to statements by City Councilwoman Sarah Parady
  2. Any prior contract drafts or proposals with different amounts
  3. All emails between city officials containing the terms "Flock", "498", "500", "threshold", or "council approval"
  4. Meeting notes or memos discussing contract structuring

This request is in the public interest as it concerns potential circumvention of democratic oversight. I request a fee waiver.

Please provide records electronically to [your email].

5) PUBLIC PRESSURE!

[edit | edit source]

SHOW UP 6 PM TO A TOWN HALL THIS WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 22ND, 6 PM, 2650 E 40th Ave, Denver, Colorado - BE THERE, I WILL BE!

Town Hall at October 22nd, 6 PM, 2650 E 40th Ave, Denver, CO 80205
Town Hall at October 22nd, 6 PM, 2650 E 40th Ave, Denver, CO 80205

References

[edit | edit source]
  1. ↑ Zialcita, Paolo; Harris, Kyle (May 5, 2025). "Denver rejects $666,000 extension for license-plate surveillance cameras after backlash". Denverite. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Prentzel, Olivia (April 21, 2026). "Colorado lawmakers weigh new limits on surveillance technology". The Colorado Sun. Archived from the original on June 14, 2026. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  3. ↑ Denver rejects Flock camera license plate readers, Denverite, May 5, 2025 (Archived)
  4. ↑ License plate readers in Denver spark mass surveillance concerns, Axios Denver, September 2, 2025 (Archived)
  5. ↑ Coalition Deeply Concerned About Use of Flock Cameras for ICE Surveillance, ACLU of Colorado (Archived)
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 Zialcita, Paolo; DeMare, Kiara (October 22, 2025). "Mayor extends Flock camera contract in Denver". Denverite. Archived from the original on June 14, 2026. Retrieved June 14, 2026. {{cite web}}: |archive-date= / |archive-url= timestamp mismatch; June 1, 2026 suggested (help)
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 Harris, Kyle (March 31, 2026). "Denver will keep surveilling license plates (with a new company) after a narrow city council vote". Denverite. Archived from the original on June 14, 2026. Retrieved June 14, 2026. {{cite web}}: |archive-date= / |archive-url= timestamp mismatch; April 2, 2026 suggested (help)
  8. ↑ Grigsby, Deborah (March 31, 2026). "Denver Council narrowly approves deal with Axon". Denver Gazette. Archived from the original on June 14, 2026. Retrieved June 14, 2026. {{cite web}}: |archive-date= / |archive-url= timestamp mismatch; May 12, 2026 suggested (help)
  9. ↑ "Denver City Council approves new Axon contract to replace Flock despite community concerns and calls for a no vote". ACLU of Colorado. April 1, 2026. Archived from the original on June 14, 2026. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  10. ↑ "Denver's license plate cameras went dark for a month. Auto theft dropped 29% anyway". 9NEWS (KUSA). 2026-06-12.
  11. ↑ 11.0 11.1 "Crime". Denver Open Data. City and County of Denver. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  12. ↑ "Crime (dataset metadata and disclaimer)". Denver Open Data. City and County of Denver. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  13. ↑ 13.0 13.1 "Colorado law cracking down on car theft credited for sharp decline". Denver Gazette. May 6, 2024. Archived from the original on June 14, 2026. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  14. ↑ "SB23-097: Motor Vehicle Theft and Unauthorized Use". Colorado General Assembly. June 2, 2023. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  15. ↑ "Senate Bill 23-097, enacted text (Section 1 amends 18-4-409; Section 2 creates 18-4-409.5)" (PDF). Colorado General Assembly. June 2, 2023. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  16. ↑ "Anti-theft software tamps down viral theft trend targeting Hyundai, Kia vehicles". Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  17. ↑ "Hyundai, Kia Campaign to Prevent Vehicle Theft". National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. February 14, 2023. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  18. ↑ 18.0 18.1 "Colorado Auto Theft Annual Report 2024" (PDF). Colorado Auto Theft Prevention Authority. Colorado State Patrol. April 9, 2025. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  19. ↑ 19.0 19.1 "Colorado Auto Theft Statistics". Rocky Mountain Insurance Information Association. Archived from the original on May 20, 2026. Retrieved June 14, 2026.
  20. ↑ Denver Charter, Page 58, Section E (Archived)
  21. ↑ Executive Order 8, Memorandum A, Page 15, Section H (Archived)
  22. ↑ Denver Purchasing Policy Manual, Page 13, September 20, 2017 (Archived)
  23. ↑ C.R.S. § 18-8-404 - First-degree official misconduct, Colorado Public Law (Archived)
  24. ↑ C.R.S. § 18-1-901 - Definitions, Justia Law (Archived)
  25. ↑ 25.0 25.1 People v. Luttrell, 636 P.2d 712 (Colo. 1981), Colorado Supreme Court
  26. ↑ C.R.S. § 18-1-901 - Definitions, Justia Law (Archived)
  27. ↑ C.R.S. § 31-15-712 - Purchases and contracts, Colorado Public Law
  28. ↑ Denver City Council rejects contract expansion for license plate recognition cameras, Denver7, May 5, 2025 (Archived)
  29. ↑ Federal immigration agents used Denver's Flock cameras 1,400 times, Colorado Newsline, August 6, 2025 (Archived)
  30. ↑ State and Federal Immigration Laws, Colorado General Assembly (Archived)
  31. ↑ Denver Revised Municipal Code § 2-51 - Declaration of policy, Municode Library
  32. ↑ City Council significantly expands approval power over city contracts, The Lens New Orleans, November 17, 2022 (Archived)