Editing Category talk:Legislation in Africa (section)

==Response to Mika==

Hi Mika, great to see you here! @[[User:Mikadago|Mikadago]]

The first thing to mention quickly is that the category pages are not for adding content to - they simply act as a directory that links together mainspace articles on the wiki. So if you wanted to add information, you wouldn't do it here, instead you'd make an article (probably using the blank template as we don't have a template for this kind of thing yet) called 'consumer protection legislation in madagascar', or something like that. It would be best to write it as an explainer, rather than simply quoting the text of the law. You can take inspiration from articles on Wikipedia about laws, such as this page on the US constitution: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_United_States. Obviously that's a very long and detailed article, but the main point is that it does not just quote the law, it is primarily focused on explaining the background and effects of the law.

Regarding sources, it's best to leave them in their original language, and just link to them. The text in the Wiki article should all be English, and should basically just present the information found in original sources. In terms of laws, editors should not do their own legal interpretation. What this means is that instead of linking to the law and saying 'these practices are allowed, these ones aren't', it is best practice to link to a legal scholar's interpretation of the law when saying what the law does and does not allow, as then the reader can verify that someone with the relevant expertise has interpreted the law, rather than the editor of the article. 

When contributing, it's probably best to start off with those shady practices that have been documented by journalists and covered extensively, as these will be the best sourced, and you'll be able to make good, fleshed out articles. Reporting on obscure or unknown issues is more difficult, as we don't allow for primary research by contributors - contributors must be referencing a source.


In any case, thank you very much for coming along and offering to contribute, and I hope to see you around! [[User:Keith|Keith]] ([[User talk:Keith|talk]]) 15:54, 16 August 2025 (UTC)

:Thanks for the clarification,
:Just removed the dummy article wrongly posted in categories.
:To be honest, i just wanted to point out that "laws" exist here, but in my opinion are seldom applied and generally ignored by the big names (who happens to be "coincidentally" close to the gov). As you can see, this legislation dates back to 2015 and has never been updated since, as far as i know. Even when the consumer's and industries' habits are not the same in 10 years.
:Just found a thesis made by a student in business law (dated 2016), i don't know if that's still relevant. I will document myself well enough first I think, and will get back here when i have something "serious" to write.
:Anyway, thanks for the openness and advice, and again, keep up the good work! You guys rock!
:Mika. [[User:Mikadago|Mikadago]] ([[User talk:Mikadago|talk]]) 20:24, 16 August 2025 (UTC)
::Thank you,
::It's really good to see people here contributing from places that often go underrepresented, and it'll provide the Wiki with some good perspective and examples on how damaging selective enforcement can be. Once we have articles about consumer protection laws in a whole range of countries, I hope it will make the Wiki a really good resource for people looking to compare and contrast how it is across different countries.
::do let me know if there's anything at all I can help you with, as I see this kind of article as something which will really improve the Wiki! [[User:Keith|Keith]] ([[User talk:Keith|talk]]) 00:12, 17 August 2025 (UTC)