Jump to content

Discord: Difference between revisions

From Consumer Rights Wiki
Fixed?
swap order in CEO text
 
(7 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Discord''' is a proprietary VoIP and instant-messaging platform developed by Discord Inc. (formerly Hammer & Chisel, Inc.) co-founded by Jason Citron and Stanislav Vishnevskiy.<ref>{{Cite web |last=Gonzalez |first=Guadalupe |date=3 May 2018 |title=There Are 2.6 Billion Online Gamers in the World. This Startup Just May Connect Them All |url=https://www.inc.com/guadalupe-gonzalez/30-under-30-2018-discord.html |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20180503131556/https://www.inc.com/guadalupe-gonzalez/30-under-30-2018-discord.html |archive-date=3 May 2018 |access-date=13 Jul 2025 |website=Inc.}}</ref> Launched in 2015, the service has grown to over 150 million monthly active users as of 2025. While primarily marketed toward gamers, Discord has expanded to serve various communities and use cases.<ref name="about-company">{{Cite web |date=15 Apr 2024 |title=About Discord <nowiki>|</nowiki> Our Mission and Values |url=https://discord.com/company/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20250608013037/https://discord.com/company |archive-date=8 Jun 2025 |access-date=13 Jul 2025 |website=Discord}}</ref><!-- Will need to re-add product box, just temp removed to see if this fixes the page - JamesTDG -->
'''Discord''' is a proprietary VoIP and instant-messaging platform developed by Discord Inc. (formerly Hammer & Chisel, Inc.) co-founded by Jason Citron and Stanislav Vishnevskiy.<ref>{{Cite web |last=Gonzalez |first=Guadalupe |date=3 May 2018 |title=There Are 2.6 Billion Online Gamers in the World. This Startup Just May Connect Them All |url=https://www.inc.com/guadalupe-gonzalez/30-under-30-2018-discord.html |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20180503131556/https://www.inc.com/guadalupe-gonzalez/30-under-30-2018-discord.html |archive-date=3 May 2018 |access-date=13 Jul 2025 |website=Inc.}}</ref> Launched in 2015, the service has grown to over 150 million monthly active users as of 2025. While initially marketed toward PC gamers, Discord has expanded to multiple platforms and serving various communities and use cases, for example, education.<ref name="about-company">{{Cite web |date=15 Apr 2024 |title=About Discord <nowiki>|</nowiki> Our Mission and Values |url=https://discord.com/company/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20250608013037/https://discord.com/company |archive-date=8 Jun 2025 |access-date=13 Jul 2025 |website=Discord}}</ref>


==Consumer impact==
In April 2025, Humam Sakhnini (formerly King, Activision Blizzard) replaced Jason Citron as CEO.<ref>{{Cite web |title=Discord Appoints Humam Sakhnini as Chief Executive Officer |url=https://discord.com/press-releases/discord-appoints-new-ceo-humam-sakhnini}}</ref> {{InfoboxCompany
====Privacy====
| Name = Discord Inc.
| Type = Private
| Founded = 2015
| Industry = Software
| Official Website = https://discord.com
| Logo = Discord.svg
}}
 
==Consumer Impact Summary==
 
===Privacy<ref name="terms-of-service3">[https://discord.com/terms/ "Discord's Terms of Service"]. April 15, 2024. ''Discord''. Retrieved January 16, 2025.</ref>===
Mentioned within the '''Discord TOS<ref name="terms-of-service3" />''' and '''Privacy Policy''':<ref name="privacy-policy3">[https://discord.com/privacy/ "Discord Privacy Policy"]. April 15, 2024. ''Discord''. Retrieved January 16, 2025.</ref><ref name="community-guidelines2">[https://discord.com/guidelines/ "Discord Community Guidelines"]. April 15, 2024. ''Discord''. Retrieved January 16, 2025.</ref>
*Collects extensive user data including messages, voice communications, and server participation.
*Collects extensive user data including messages, voice communications, and server participation.
*Claims broad rights to user-generated content through terms of service.
*Claims broad rights to user-generated content.
*May store deleted messages for undefined periods.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Deleted messages are stored for undefined periods.
*Retains personal information until deemed "no longer needed" with unclear retention periods.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Retains personal information until deemed "no longer needed" with undefined retention periods.
*Processes user content for safety features and platform improvement.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Processes user content for "safety features and platform improvement".
*Shares data with related companies, vendors, and third-party service providers.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Shares data with related companies, vendors, and third-party service providers.
*Uses behavioral tracking across platform features for personalization.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Opt-out behavioral tracking across platform features for personalization.
*Maintains logs of IP addresses and device information.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Maintains logs of IP addresses and device information for an undetermined amount of time, flags any user who has ever signed in with an EU IP address for inclusion within DSA transparency reports
*Sends a web request when any UI element is clicked & when typing
*Phone number randomly required, will lock account until a phone number is added regardless of account age or recent activity. Account will be automatically locked if phone number is removed
 
===Freedom===
Mentioned within the '''Discord TOS<ref name="terms-of-service3" />''' and '''Privacy Policy''':<ref name="privacy-policy3" />
*Mandatory [[Forced Arbitration|binding arbitration]] with [[class action|class-action]] waiver for U.S. users (Started 15 May 2024).
*Users grant perpetual, transferable license to their content.
*Users must accept broad terms of service that allow unilateral changes.
*Can terminate accounts without prior notice at Discord's discretion.


=== Freedom ===
*No option to opt out of core data collection while using the service.
*Mandatory [[Forced Arbitration|binding arbitration]] with [[class action|class-action]] waiver for U.S. users (Started 15 May 2024).<ref name="terms-of-service" />
*Content may be retained by Discord even after deletion.
*Users grant perpetual, transferable license to their content.<ref name="terms-of-service" />
*Server owners have limited recourse if their servers are banned.
*Users must accept broad terms of service that allow unilateral changes.<ref name="terms-of-service" />
*Forced to use Discord's payment processing for all monetary transactions.
*Can terminate accounts without prior notice at Discord's discretion.<ref name="terms-of-service" />
*No option to opt out of core data collection while using the service.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Content may be retained by Discord even after deletion.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Server owners have limited recourse if their servers are banned.<ref name="terms-of-service" />
*Forced to use Discord's payment processing for all monetary transactions.<ref name="terms-of-service" />


=== Transparency ===
===Transparency===
*Unclear processes for handling law enforcement requests.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
Mentioned within the '''Discord Privacy Policy'''<ref name="privacy-policy3" /> and '''Community Guidelines''':<ref name="community-guidelines2" />
*Vague about specific data retention time frames.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Unclear processes for handling law enforcement requests.
*Privacy policy written in relatively clear language compared to industry standards.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Vague about specific data retention time frames.
*Provides clear community guidelines with defined enforcement procedures.
*Limited transparency regarding content moderation decisions.<ref name=":0">{{Cite web |title=BBB - Discord, Inc. |url=https://www.bbb.org/us/ca/san-francisco/profile/computer-software/discord-inc-1116-918699 |access-date=Aug 2, 2025 |website=[[Better Business Bureau]]}}</ref><ref name=":1">{{Cite web |title=Trustpilot - Discord |url=https://www.trustpilot.com/review/discord.com |access-date=Aug 2, 2025 |website=Trustpilot}}</ref>
*Limited transparency regarding content moderation decisions.<ref name="community-guidelines" />
**In certain cases, the offending content is not shown to the user, nor any metadata, filenames, timestamps or even the originating channel
*Server ban appeals process lacks transparency.<ref name="community-guidelines" />
**No limits or restrictions on the age of content (e.g users can be suspended due to something sent 1500 days ago)
*Limited disclosure of recommendation algorithm factors.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Server ban appeals process lacks transparency.<ref name=":0" /><ref name=":1" />
*No clear disclosure of how content is used for platform improvement.<ref name="privacy-policy" />
*Limited disclosure of recommendation algorithm factors.
*No clear disclosure of how content is used for platform improvement.
==Consumer-protection incidents==
==Consumer-protection incidents==
===FTC data collection investigation (Sep. 2024)===
===FTC data collection investigation (Sep. 2024)===
Line 53: Line 69:


===Introduction of forced arbitration (Mar. 2024)===
===Introduction of forced arbitration (Mar. 2024)===
In March 2024, Discord users were notified via email that [[Forced Arbitration|forced arbitration]] would be added to the [[Terms of Service|terms of service]] effective 15 April 2024. Users could opt out by sending an 'opt-out notice' to [email protected] within the thirty days preceding 15 April 2024, or registration of their first account.<ref name="terms-of-service" />
In March 2024, Discord users were notified via email that [[Forced Arbitration|forced arbitration]] would be added to the [[Terms of Service|terms of service]] effective 15 April 2024. Users could opt out by sending an 'opt-out notice' to [email protected] within the thirty days preceding 15 April 2024, or registration of their first account.'''<ref name="terms-of-service3" />'''


===Child safety concerns (Jun. 2023)===
===Child safety concerns (Jun. 2023)===
Line 62: Line 78:
===Irresponsible moderation practices===
===Irresponsible moderation practices===
{{Main|Discord's irresponsible moderation}}
{{Main|Discord's irresponsible moderation}}
Reported countlessly by users on the BBB and Trustpilot, users have complained about how Discord's moderation is extremely vague. One such user reported their account being banned to the BBB,<ref>{{Cite web |last=Mir |first=Zain |date=Jul 23, 2025 |title=BBB Complaint |url=https://www.bbb.org/us/ca/san-francisco/profile/computer-software/discord-inc-1116-918699/complaints?page=2#1116_918699_23643523 |access-date=Aug 1, 2025 |website=Better Business Bureau}}</ref> with an automated system handling the entire process, without having a human involved in the appeal process.
[[File:Discord Vague Infringement example.png|thumb|An example of how Discord handles its moderation from the perspective of a user.]]
Reported countlessly by users on the BBB<ref name=":0" />, Trustpilot,<ref name=":1" /> and a dedicated subreddit<ref>{{Cite web |title=/r/BannedFromDiscord |url=https://old.reddit.com/r/BannedFromDiscord/}}</ref> users have complained about how Discord's moderation is extremely vague. One such user reported their account being banned to the BBB,<ref>{{Cite web |last=Mir |first=Zain |date=Jul 23, 2025 |title=BBB Complaint |url=https://www.bbb.org/us/ca/san-francisco/profile/computer-software/discord-inc-1116-918699/complaints?page=2#1116_918699_23643523 |access-date=Aug 1, 2025 |website=Better Business Bureau}}</ref> with an automated system handling the entire process replying only with templates, without having a human involved in the appeal process.


==References==
==References==

Latest revision as of 02:54, 15 August 2025

Discord is a proprietary VoIP and instant-messaging platform developed by Discord Inc. (formerly Hammer & Chisel, Inc.) co-founded by Jason Citron and Stanislav Vishnevskiy.[1] Launched in 2015, the service has grown to over 150 million monthly active users as of 2025. While initially marketed toward PC gamers, Discord has expanded to multiple platforms and serving various communities and use cases, for example, education.[2]

In April 2025, Humam Sakhnini (formerly King, Activision Blizzard) replaced Jason Citron as CEO.[3]

Discord
Basic information
Founded 2015
Legal structure Private
Industry Software
Official website https://discord.com


Consumer Impact Summary[edit | edit source]

Privacy[4][edit | edit source]

Mentioned within the Discord TOS[4] and Privacy Policy:[5][6]

  • Collects extensive user data including messages, voice communications, and server participation.
  • Claims broad rights to user-generated content.
  • Deleted messages are stored for undefined periods.
  • Retains personal information until deemed "no longer needed" with undefined retention periods.
  • Processes user content for "safety features and platform improvement".
  • Shares data with related companies, vendors, and third-party service providers.
  • Opt-out behavioral tracking across platform features for personalization.
  • Maintains logs of IP addresses and device information for an undetermined amount of time, flags any user who has ever signed in with an EU IP address for inclusion within DSA transparency reports
  • Sends a web request when any UI element is clicked & when typing
  • Phone number randomly required, will lock account until a phone number is added regardless of account age or recent activity. Account will be automatically locked if phone number is removed

Freedom[edit | edit source]

Mentioned within the Discord TOS[4] and Privacy Policy:[5]

  • Mandatory binding arbitration with class-action waiver for U.S. users (Started 15 May 2024).
  • Users grant perpetual, transferable license to their content.
  • Users must accept broad terms of service that allow unilateral changes.
  • Can terminate accounts without prior notice at Discord's discretion.
  • No option to opt out of core data collection while using the service.
  • Content may be retained by Discord even after deletion.
  • Server owners have limited recourse if their servers are banned.
  • Forced to use Discord's payment processing for all monetary transactions.

Transparency[edit | edit source]

Mentioned within the Discord Privacy Policy[5] and Community Guidelines:[6]

  • Unclear processes for handling law enforcement requests.
  • Vague about specific data retention time frames.
  • Limited transparency regarding content moderation decisions.[7][8]
    • In certain cases, the offending content is not shown to the user, nor any metadata, filenames, timestamps or even the originating channel
    • No limits or restrictions on the age of content (e.g users can be suspended due to something sent 1500 days ago)
  • Server ban appeals process lacks transparency.[7][8]
  • Limited disclosure of recommendation algorithm factors.
  • No clear disclosure of how content is used for platform improvement.

Consumer-protection incidents[edit | edit source]

FTC data collection investigation (Sep. 2024)[edit | edit source]

In September 2024, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) released a comprehensive report examining Discord's data-collection practices as part of a broader investigation into social-media platforms.[9]

The investigation revealed Discord collects extensive user data, including:

  • Message content and metadata
  • Voice-chat participation
  • Server membership and activity
  • Device and location information

Particular concern was raised about:

  • Collection of data from users under 13
  • Handling of minor user information
  • Inadequate age-verification systems

The FTC identified multiple areas where Discord's practices put users at risk:

  • Identity-theft exposure
  • Potential stalking risks
  • Discrimination concerns
  • Mental health and emotional impact

The FTC concluded that Discord's data practices created unacceptable risks for users, particularly minors, and called for significant reforms to the platform's privacy protection measures.[10]

Introduction of forced arbitration (Mar. 2024)[edit | edit source]

In March 2024, Discord users were notified via email that forced arbitration would be added to the terms of service effective 15 April 2024. Users could opt out by sending an 'opt-out notice' to [email protected] within the thirty days preceding 15 April 2024, or registration of their first account.[4]

Child safety concerns (Jun. 2023)[edit | edit source]

An NBC News investigation in June 2023[11] uncovered widespread child-safety issues on Discord, revealing systemic problems with the platform's user protection measures.

Investigators identified 35 separate cases where adults were criminally charged with "kidnapping, grooming, or sexual assault" involving contacts initiated through Discord. Additionally, 165 criminal prosecutions involving the sharing of child sexual exploitation material on the platform were documented.

Irresponsible moderation practices[edit | edit source]

Main article: Discord's irresponsible moderation
An example of how Discord handles its moderation from the perspective of a user.

Reported countlessly by users on the BBB[7], Trustpilot,[8] and a dedicated subreddit[12] users have complained about how Discord's moderation is extremely vague. One such user reported their account being banned to the BBB,[13] with an automated system handling the entire process replying only with templates, without having a human involved in the appeal process.

References[edit | edit source]

  1. Gonzalez, Guadalupe (3 May 2018). "There Are 2.6 Billion Online Gamers in the World. This Startup Just May Connect Them All". Inc. Archived from the original on 3 May 2018. Retrieved 13 Jul 2025.
  2. "About Discord | Our Mission and Values". Discord. 15 Apr 2024. Archived from the original on 8 Jun 2025. Retrieved 13 Jul 2025.
  3. "Discord Appoints Humam Sakhnini as Chief Executive Officer".
  4. 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 "Discord's Terms of Service". April 15, 2024. Discord. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
  5. 5.0 5.1 5.2 "Discord Privacy Policy". April 15, 2024. Discord. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
  6. 6.0 6.1 "Discord Community Guidelines". April 15, 2024. Discord. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
  7. 7.0 7.1 7.2 "BBB - Discord, Inc". Better Business Bureau. Retrieved Aug 2, 2025.
  8. 8.0 8.1 8.2 "Trustpilot - Discord". Trustpilot. Retrieved Aug 2, 2025.
  9. "A Look Behind the Screens: Examining the Data Practices of Social Media and Video Streaming Services" (PDF). Federal Trade Commission. 11 Sep 2024. Archived (PDF) from the original on 19 Sep 2024. Retrieved 13 Jul 2025.
  10. Tolentino, Daysia (19 Sep 2024). "Social media companies engaged in 'vast surveillance,' FTC finds, calling status quo 'unacceptable'". NBC News. Archived from the original on 19 Sep 2024. Retrieved 13 Jul 2025.
  11. Goggin, Ben (21 Jun 2023). "Child predators are using Discord, a popular app among teens, for sextortion and abductions". NBC News. Archived from the original on 21 Jun 2023. Retrieved 13 Jul 2025.
  12. "/r/BannedFromDiscord".
  13. Mir, Zain (Jul 23, 2025). "BBB Complaint". Better Business Bureau. Retrieved Aug 1, 2025.