Right to own: Difference between revisions

Line 1:

The '''right to own''' is the right for consumers to be able to completely own their products. The Consumer Rights Wiki (CRW) believes that a consumer only owns their product if they have full control over it. Ownership is a key concept to consumer rights protection.

The '''right to own''' is the right for consumers to be able to completely own their products. The Consumer Rights Wiki (CRW) believes that a consumer only owns their product if they have full control over it.{{Citation needed|reason=This sounds like a statement of policy, needs to be tied back to the source to show that it is true.}} Ownership is a key concept to consumer rights protection.

==Extent of the right to own==

Line 6:

==Subscription-Only Products (Software as a Service, SaaS)==

If control is revocable, the consumer does not own their product. A consumer does not own their product if they pay a [[Subscription service|subscription]] for continued use. A consumer does not own their product if it [[Discontinuation bricking|bricks itself]] when the company goes out of business~~<ref>insert reference to company going out of business and bricking the device here</ref>~~ or decides to [[Spotify Car Thing|discontinue production]]. Many software products which used to sell unlimited licenses to use and reinstall the software forever are now subscription only.

If control is revocable, the consumer does not own their product. A consumer does not own their product if they pay a [[Subscription service|subscription]] for continued use. A consumer does not own their product if it [[Discontinuation bricking|bricks itself]] when the company goes out of business or decides to [[Spotify Car Thing|discontinue production]]. Many software products which used to sell unlimited licenses to use and reinstall the software forever are now subscription only.

'''Examples:''' [[Adobe]], [[Microsoft]], [[IoT]] Devices that rely on servers and services outside your home, with or without subscriptions

'''Examples:''' [[Adobe]], [[Microsoft]], [[IoT]] Devices that rely on [[Cloud|servers and services outside your home]], with or without subscriptions

==Anti-Repair Design==

A consumer does not own their product if they are unable to [[Right to repair|repair]] their device themselves due to the company going out of its way to make unauthorized repair impossible.~~<ref>~~Insert reference to apple doing this. Note: make a page about the Apple repair program being inadequate (change this from reference to direct link preferably. [[Apple authorized repair~~]]</ref>~~ This include things like the proprietary calibration software which [[Apple]] refuses to provide to third parties and which Apple Youtubers claim is a "feature to improve performance and security". This could also include devices made to throw away when a wear component, such as batteries, breaks after a few years, and cannot be repaired, a perfect example being [[Airpods]].

A consumer does not own their product if they are unable to [[Right to repair|repair]] their device themselves due to the company going out of its way to make unauthorized repair impossible.{{Citation needed|reason=Insert reference to apple doing this. Note: make a page about the Apple repair program being inadequate (change this from reference to direct link preferably. Apple authorized repair}} This include things like the proprietary calibration software which [[Apple]] refuses to provide to third parties and which Apple Youtubers claim is a "feature to improve performance and security". This could also include devices made to throw away when a wear component, such as batteries, breaks after a few years, and cannot be repaired, a perfect example being [[Airpods]].

==Poor Security==

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 {{StubNotice}}
-The '''right to own''' is the right for consumers to be able to completely own their products. The Consumer Rights Wiki (CRW) believes that a consumer only owns their product if they have full control over it. Ownership is a key concept to consumer rights protection.
+The '''right to own''' is the right for consumers to be able to completely own their products. The Consumer Rights Wiki (CRW) believes that a consumer only owns their product if they have full control over it.{{Citation needed|reason=This sounds like a statement of policy, needs to be tied back to the source to show that it is true.}} Ownership is a key concept to consumer rights protection.
 ==Extent of the right to own==
@@ Line 6: / Line 6: @@
 ==Subscription-Only Products (Software as a Service, SaaS)==
-If control is revocable, the consumer does not own their product. A consumer does not own their product if they pay a [[Subscription service|subscription]] for continued use. A consumer does not own their product if it [[Discontinuation bricking|bricks itself]] when the company goes out of business<ref>insert reference to company going out of business and bricking the device here</ref> or decides to [[Spotify Car Thing|discontinue production]]. Many software products which used to sell unlimited licenses to use and reinstall the software forever are now subscription only.
+If control is revocable, the consumer does not own their product. A consumer does not own their product if they pay a [[Subscription service|subscription]] for continued use. A consumer does not own their product if it [[Discontinuation bricking|bricks itself]] when the company goes out of business or decides to [[Spotify Car Thing|discontinue production]]. Many software products which used to sell unlimited licenses to use and reinstall the software forever are now subscription only.
-'''Examples:''' [[Adobe]], [[Microsoft]], [[IoT]] Devices that rely on servers and services outside your home, with or without subscriptions
+'''Examples:''' [[Adobe]], [[Microsoft]], [[IoT]] Devices that rely on [[Cloud|servers and services outside your home]], with or without subscriptions
 ==Anti-Repair Design==
-A consumer does not own their product if they are unable to [[Right to repair|repair]] their device themselves due to the company going out of its way to make unauthorized repair impossible.<ref>Insert reference to apple doing this. Note: make a page about the Apple repair program being inadequate (change this from reference to direct link preferably. [[Apple authorized repair]]</ref> This include things like the proprietary calibration software which [[Apple]] refuses to provide to third parties and which Apple Youtubers claim is a "feature to improve performance and security". This could also include devices made to throw away when a wear component, such as batteries, breaks after a few years, and cannot be repaired, a perfect example being [[Airpods]].
+A consumer does not own their product if they are unable to [[Right to repair|repair]] their device themselves due to the company going out of its way to make unauthorized repair impossible.{{Citation needed|reason=Insert reference to apple doing this. Note: make a page about the Apple repair program being inadequate (change this from reference to direct link preferably. Apple authorized repair}} This include things like the proprietary calibration software which [[Apple]] refuses to provide to third parties and which Apple Youtubers claim is a "feature to improve performance and security". This could also include devices made to throw away when a wear component, such as batteries, breaks after a few years, and cannot be repaired, a perfect example being [[Airpods]].
 ==Poor Security==