AlienRides LLC tries and bans all importation of Electric Unicycles using patent law unless licensing fee is paid.: Difference between revisions
I added what a consumer can do and how to file a public notice |
mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
https://www.usitc.gov/secretary/fed_reg | https://www.usitc.gov/secretary/fed_reg | ||
}} | }} | ||
==Background== | ==Background== | ||
Electric Unicycles are a hobby in the United States where a person rides a one wheel device using the motor to power and balance itself. It is enjoyed by thousands of people with its own events and culture | Electric Unicycles are a hobby in the United States where a person rides a one wheel device using the motor to power and balance itself. It is enjoyed by thousands of people with its own events and culture | ||
| Line 83: | Line 82: | ||
---- | ---- | ||
=== Phase 1: Registration (Mandatory) === | ===Phase 1: Registration (Mandatory)=== | ||
You cannot submit anonymously. You must have a registered account to file. | You cannot submit anonymously. You must have a registered account to file. | ||
# '''Go to the Portal:''' Visit edis.usitc.gov. | #'''Go to the Portal:''' Visit edis.usitc.gov. | ||
# '''Register:''' Click the '''"Register"''' link on the homepage. | #'''Register:''' Click the '''"Register"''' link on the homepage. | ||
# '''User Profile:''' Fill out the required fields. | #'''User Profile:''' Fill out the required fields. | ||
#* '''Association:''' If you are an individual rider, select '''"None/Other"''' or '''"Not Listed"''' for Firm/Organization. | #*'''Association:''' If you are an individual rider, select '''"None/Other"''' or '''"Not Listed"''' for Firm/Organization. | ||
#* '''Email:''' Use a permanent email address; you will receive your official filing receipt here. | #*'''Email:''' Use a permanent email address; you will receive your official filing receipt here. | ||
# '''Activate:''' Check your email for an activation link to verify your account. | #'''Activate:''' Check your email for an activation link to verify your account. | ||
---- | ---- | ||
=== Phase 2: Preparing Your Document === | ===Phase 2: Preparing Your Document=== | ||
The ITC will reject submissions that do not meet their technical standards. | The ITC will reject submissions that do not meet their technical standards. | ||
* '''Format:''' Your document '''MUST''' be a PDF. The system will not accept Word or image files. | *'''Format:''' Your document '''MUST''' be a PDF. The system will not accept Word or image files. | ||
* '''Length:''' Your statement is limited to '''five (5) pages''' maximum, including any attachments. | *'''Length:''' Your statement is limited to '''five (5) pages''' maximum, including any attachments. | ||
* '''Header:''' Place '''"Docket No. 3877"''' in bold at the top of the first page so it is indexed correctly. | *'''Header:''' Place '''"Docket No. 3877"''' in bold at the top of the first page so it is indexed correctly. | ||
* '''The "Big Five" Content:''' To be legally valid, your PDF must address these 5 points: | *'''The "Big Five" Content:''' To be legally valid, your PDF must address these 5 points: | ||
*# '''Usage:''' How you use EUCs (e.g., green commuting). | *#'''Usage:''' How you use EUCs (e.g., green commuting). | ||
*# '''Welfare:''' Any safety or environmental concerns (e.g., a ban forces people into cars). | *#'''Welfare:''' Any safety or environmental concerns (e.g., a ban forces people into cars). | ||
*# '''Competitive Articles:''' Are there any U.S.-made alternatives? (Currently, there are no high-performance EUCs made in the USA). | *#'''Competitive Articles:''' Are there any U.S.-made alternatives? (Currently, there are no high-performance EUCs made in the USA). | ||
*# '''Replacement Capacity:''' Does the complainant (Alien Rides) have the space/funding to replace the entire U.S. supply? (Reference the <4,000 sq ft facility vs the required 20,000+ sq ft). | *#'''Replacement Capacity:''' Does the complainant (Alien Rides) have the space/funding to replace the entire U.S. supply? (Reference the <4,000 sq ft facility vs the required 20,000+ sq ft). | ||
*# '''Consumer Impact:''' How a ban harms riders (e.g., immediate 30% price hikes or no parts). | *#'''Consumer Impact:''' How a ban harms riders (e.g., immediate 30% price hikes or no parts). | ||
---- | ---- | ||
=== Phase 3: The Electronic Filing (The "Hard" Part) === | ===Phase 3: The Electronic Filing (The "Hard" Part)=== | ||
Once logged into EDIS, follow this exact click-path: | Once logged into EDIS, follow this exact click-path: | ||
# '''Start Filing:''' Click the '''"Submission"''' tab and select '''"File a New Document."''' | #'''Start Filing:''' Click the '''"Submission"''' tab and select '''"File a New Document."''' | ||
# '''Investigation Type:''' Select '''"Sec 337"''' from the dropdown menu. | #'''Investigation Type:''' Select '''"Sec 337"''' from the dropdown menu. | ||
# '''Search for the Case:''' * Enter '''3877''' in the "Investigation Number" field. | #'''Search for the Case:''' * Enter '''3877''' in the "Investigation Number" field. | ||
#* Click '''Search'''. | #*Click '''Search'''. | ||
#* Select '''"Certain Gyro-Stabilized Electric Unicycles"''' from the results. | #*Select '''"Certain Gyro-Stabilized Electric Unicycles"''' from the results. | ||
# '''Select Phase:''' Choose '''"Violation"''' as the investigation phase. | #'''Select Phase:''' Choose '''"Violation"''' as the investigation phase. | ||
# '''Document Metadata:''' | #'''Document Metadata:''' | ||
#* '''Document Type:''' Select '''"Public Interest Statement."''' | #*'''Document Type:''' Select '''"Public Interest Statement."''' | ||
#* '''Document Title:''' Enter "Public Interest Comment - [Your Name/Company Name]." | #*'''Document Title:''' Enter "Public Interest Comment - [Your Name/Company Name]." | ||
#* '''Security Level:''' Select '''"Public"''' (and click '''"No"''' when asked if it contains confidential info). | #*'''Security Level:''' Select '''"Public"''' (and click '''"No"''' when asked if it contains confidential info). | ||
# '''Upload & Submit:''' * Click '''"Add Files"''' and select your PDF. | #'''Upload & Submit:''' * Click '''"Add Files"''' and select your PDF. | ||
#* Review the information for accuracy. | #*Review the information for accuracy. | ||
#* Click '''"Submit."''' | #*Click '''"Submit."''' | ||
---- | ---- | ||
=== Phase 4: Confirmation === | ===Phase 4: Confirmation=== | ||
* '''The Receipt:''' You will see a confirmation screen with a '''6-digit Document ID'''. '''Capture a screenshot of this.''' | *'''The Receipt:''' You will see a confirmation screen with a '''6-digit Document ID'''. '''Capture a screenshot of this.''' | ||
* '''The Email:''' You will receive an automated email from the USITC confirming the filing. Keep this for your records as proof of submission. | *'''The Email:''' You will receive an automated email from the USITC confirming the filing. Keep this for your records as proof of submission. | ||
<blockquote>'''CRITICAL DEADLINE:''' All submissions must be received by the close of business on '''February 3, 2026'''. Filing even 15 minutes late can result in your testimony being excluded from the record. | <blockquote>'''CRITICAL DEADLINE:''' All submissions must be received by the close of business on '''February 3, 2026'''. Filing even 15 minutes late can result in your testimony being excluded from the record. | ||
| Line 148: | Line 147: | ||
'''II. Public Interest Factors:''' | '''II. Public Interest Factors:''' | ||
* '''(i) Usage in the U.S.:''' I use my EUC as a primary mode of green, zero-emission transportation. These devices provide critical "last-mile" connectivity to public transit and reduce urban traffic congestion. | *'''(i) Usage in the U.S.:''' I use my EUC as a primary mode of green, zero-emission transportation. These devices provide critical "last-mile" connectivity to public transit and reduce urban traffic congestion. | ||
* '''(ii) Public Health, Safety, and Welfare:''' A ban on these imports would force me and thousands of others back into gas-powered vehicles, increasing the carbon footprint and removing a safety-tested micro-mobility option from the market. | *'''(ii) Public Health, Safety, and Welfare:''' A ban on these imports would force me and thousands of others back into gas-powered vehicles, increasing the carbon footprint and removing a safety-tested micro-mobility option from the market. | ||
* '''(iii) Competitive Articles:''' There are currently '''no''' high-performance electric unicycles manufactured within the United States that can serve as a viable substitute for the models targeted in this complaint. | *'''(iii) Competitive Articles:''' There are currently '''no''' high-performance electric unicycles manufactured within the United States that can serve as a viable substitute for the models targeted in this complaint. | ||
* '''(iv) Capacity to Replace:''' The complainants (Inventist and Alien Rides) operate out of a shared retail/repair facility of less than 4,000 square feet. This infrastructure is physically insufficient to store or manufacture the thousands of units required to satisfy U.S. consumer demand. | *'''(iv) Capacity to Replace:''' The complainants (Inventist and Alien Rides) operate out of a shared retail/repair facility of less than 4,000 square feet. This infrastructure is physically insufficient to store or manufacture the thousands of units required to satisfy U.S. consumer demand. | ||
* '''(v) Impact on Consumers:''' An exclusion order would create an artificial monopoly, leading to an immediate 30% or higher increase in consumer costs and a total lack of spare parts, effectively rendering existing vehicles unserviceable and unsafe. | *'''(v) Impact on Consumers:''' An exclusion order would create an artificial monopoly, leading to an immediate 30% or higher increase in consumer costs and a total lack of spare parts, effectively rendering existing vehicles unserviceable and unsafe. | ||
'''III. Conclusion:''' I urge the Commission to deny the requested exclusion order to protect consumer choice and green transit.</blockquote> | '''III. Conclusion:''' I urge the Commission to deny the requested exclusion order to protect consumer choice and green transit.</blockquote> | ||
----'''Template 2: For EUC Vendors / Repair Shops''' | ----'''Template 2: For EUC Vendors / Repair Shops''' | ||
| Line 162: | Line 160: | ||
'''II. Public Interest Factors:''' | '''II. Public Interest Factors:''' | ||
* '''(iii) Competitive Articles:''' As a professional dealer of [X], I can verify that there are no domestic (U.S.-made) alternatives to the targeted imports from Begode, InMotion, LeaperKim, KingSong, or Nosfet. | *'''(iii) Competitive Articles:''' As a professional dealer of [X], I can verify that there are no domestic (U.S.-made) alternatives to the targeted imports from Begode, InMotion, LeaperKim, KingSong, or Nosfet. | ||
* '''(iv) Capacity to Replace:''' To support the U.S. market, a manufacturer requires a logistics and warehousing footprint exceeding 20,000 square feet per brand. The complainant’s shared 4,000 sq ft facility lacks the operational scale to fulfill national demand. Granting a ban would leave the market entirely unserved. | *'''(iv) Capacity to Replace:''' To support the U.S. market, a manufacturer requires a logistics and warehousing footprint exceeding 20,000 square feet per brand. The complainant’s shared 4,000 sq ft facility lacks the operational scale to fulfill national demand. Granting a ban would leave the market entirely unserved. | ||
* '''(v) Impact on Consumers:''' A ban would prevent U.S. owners from accessing critical safety repairs and batteries. Furthermore, the Nov 14, 2025, Court of Appeals ruling (Case 24-1010) already established that modern recessed designs are non-infringing. Pursuing a ban against these products harms the integrity of the U.S. retail market. | *'''(v) Impact on Consumers:''' A ban would prevent U.S. owners from accessing critical safety repairs and batteries. Furthermore, the Nov 14, 2025, Court of Appeals ruling (Case 24-1010) already established that modern recessed designs are non-infringing. Pursuing a ban against these products harms the integrity of the U.S. retail market. | ||
'''III. Conclusion:''' The Commission should decline to institute this investigation to protect U.S. small businesses and the competitive market.</blockquote> | '''III. Conclusion:''' The Commission should decline to institute this investigation to protect U.S. small businesses and the competitive market.</blockquote> | ||
----'''Template 3: For Accessory Manufacturers (USA & Global)''' | ----'''Template 3: For Accessory Manufacturers (USA & Global)''' | ||
| Line 174: | Line 171: | ||
'''II. Public Interest Factors:''' | '''II. Public Interest Factors:''' | ||
* '''(iii) Competitive Articles:''' Our products are designed specifically for the imported models from the "Big Five" manufacturers. If these imports are banned, there are no U.S.-made vehicles for which our products can be adapted. | *'''(iii) Competitive Articles:''' Our products are designed specifically for the imported models from the "Big Five" manufacturers. If these imports are banned, there are no U.S.-made vehicles for which our products can be adapted. | ||
* '''(iv) Capacity to Replace:''' The complainants have zero manufacturing capability for the scale required. A U.S. import ban would lead to the insolvency of global manufacturers, which in turn destroys the global accessory ecosystem. | *'''(iv) Capacity to Replace:''' The complainants have zero manufacturing capability for the scale required. A U.S. import ban would lead to the insolvency of global manufacturers, which in turn destroys the global accessory ecosystem. | ||
* '''(v) Impact on Consumers:''' This ban would result in a "monopoly tax" that would increase the cost of this entire sport/industry by 30%, making specialized safety gear and performance upgrades economically unfeasible for most riders. | *'''(v) Impact on Consumers:''' This ban would result in a "monopoly tax" that would increase the cost of this entire sport/industry by 30%, making specialized safety gear and performance upgrades economically unfeasible for most riders. | ||
'''III. Conclusion:''' Protect the global innovation ecosystem by denying this request for a General Exclusion Order.</blockquote> | '''III. Conclusion:''' Protect the global innovation ecosystem by denying this request for a General Exclusion Order.</blockquote> | ||
----'''Filing Reminder''' | ----'''Filing Reminder''' | ||
* '''Format:''' Must be a '''PDF'''. | *'''Format:''' Must be a '''PDF'''. | ||
* '''Length:''' Maximum '''5 pages'''. | *'''Length:''' Maximum '''5 pages'''. | ||
* '''Deadline:''' Close of business, '''February 3, 2026'''. | *'''Deadline:''' Close of business, '''February 3, 2026'''. | ||
* '''Case No:''' Docket No. 3877. | *'''Case No:''' Docket No. 3877. | ||
</blockquote> | </blockquote> | ||
| Line 194: | Line 190: | ||
===Alien Rides Response=== | ===Alien Rides Response=== | ||
{{Ph-I-C}} | {{Ph-I-C}} | ||
<references /> | |||