Safe Digital Environments Law: Difference between revisions
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
==Consumer response== | ==Consumer response== | ||
The legislation project has received mixed responses, with some users approving it and other rejecting and critizicing its effectiveness. | The legislation project has received mixed responses and generated a broad debate in media, with some users approving it and other rejecting and critizicing its effectiveness. Experts claim the possibility to implement such age verification systems in the country is something difficult, along with the implementation of ClaveÚnica as the method of age verification raises privacy concerns as the statal system is tied with a person's identity. Johannes Kaiser, representative of the National Libertarian Party (PNL) responded claiming the addition of these restrictions are violating the rigths of privacy and freedom and granting the State to surveil Chileans on the net.<ref>{{Cite web |last=Campos |first=Sofía|date=15 Jun 2026 |title=¿Más protección o vulneración de derechos? Uso de ClaveÚnica para redes sociales de menores abre debate entre expertos |trans-title=More protection or rights vulneration? Usage of ClaveÚnica for social media for minors opens debate amongst experts |url=https://www.emol.com/noticias/Nacional/2026/06/15/1202874/clave-unica-redes-sociales-menores.html |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20260615231935/https://www.emol.com/noticias/Nacional/2026/06/15/1202874/clave-unica-redes-sociales-menores.html |archive-date=2026-06-15|access-date=15 Jun 2026 |website=Emol}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |last=apellido |first=nombre |date=13 Jun 2026 |title=¿Ingreso de menores a RR.SS. mediante Clave Única?: La idea del Gobierno que abrió debate entre expertos |trans-title=Minors accessing to social media using Clave Única?: The Government's idea that opened a debate among experts |url=https://www.emol.com/noticias/Nacional/2026/06/13/1202730/redes-sociales-clave-unica-mideso.html |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20260615232402/https://www.emol.com/noticias/Nacional/2026/06/13/1202730/redes-sociales-clave-unica-mideso.html |archive-date=2026-06-15 |access-date=15 Jun 2026 |website=Emol}}</ref> | ||
Several users on [[Reddit]], in the r/chile subreddit have manifested their concerns with privacy, risks of data breaches, censorship concerns and concerns about the potential expansion of the ban to more sites of the internet, as the project is looking to follow similar international legislations. Some users have also highlighted the incompatibility of the project with the Net Neutrality Law, an established law that prevents telecommunication services to arbitrarily block, interfere or restrict the access to legal content online.<ref>{{Cite web |date=|title=Ministra Wulf adelantó posible control de edad en RRSS a través de ClaveÚnica: qué se sabe hasta ahora |trans-title=Minister Wulf forwarded possible age control on social media trough ClaveÚnica: what it is known for now|url=https://www.old.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1u42z0z/ministra_wulf_adelant%C3%B3_posible_control_de_edad_en/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20260613010140/https://www.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1u42z0z/ministra_wulf_adelant%C3%B3_posible_control_de_edad_en/?solution=dfc06a2675df1461dfc06a2675df1461&js_challenge=1&token=7afd7253fec22262ff1c52b1703fe9ec1b5c0be6faef3a5c8e49a1e48c0baeb3&jsc_orig_r=|archive-date=2026-06-13|access-date=12 Jun 2026 |website=Reddit}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |date=May 2026 |title=Ya chiquillos. Es hora de detener el AGE CHECK juntos. |trans-title=Ok guys, it's time to stop the AGE CHECK together. |url=https://www.old.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1t6qrh9/ya_chiquillos_es_hora_de_deterner_el_age_check/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20260613011035/https://www.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1t6qrh9/ya_chiquillos_es_hora_de_deterner_el_age_check/?solution=84b9d3b4a9161dc484b9d3b4a9161dc4&js_challenge=1&token=7afd7253fec22262ff1c52b1703fe9ecf85b607bd3e42b2d71525a281a8ace07&jsc_orig_r= |archive-date=2026-06-13 |access-date=12 Jun 2026 |website=Reddit}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |date= |title=Chile copia a Inglaterra la ley "Online Safety Act" de Reino unido , creando la censura total de internet, esta ley es la de mayor alcance desde que existe internet en chile. ellos dicen textualmente que es una copia exacta de la ley inglesa | |||
Several users in social media, specially on [[Reddit]], in the r/chile subreddit have manifested their concerns with privacy, risks of data breaches, censorship concerns and concerns about the potential expansion of the ban to more sites of the internet, as the project is looking to follow similar international legislations. Some users have also highlighted the incompatibility of the project with the Net Neutrality Law, an established law that prevents telecommunication services to arbitrarily block, interfere or restrict the access to legal content online.<ref>{{Cite web |date=|title=Ministra Wulf adelantó posible control de edad en RRSS a través de ClaveÚnica: qué se sabe hasta ahora |trans-title=Minister Wulf forwarded possible age control on social media trough ClaveÚnica: what it is known for now|url=https://www.old.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1u42z0z/ministra_wulf_adelant%C3%B3_posible_control_de_edad_en/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20260613010140/https://www.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1u42z0z/ministra_wulf_adelant%C3%B3_posible_control_de_edad_en/?solution=dfc06a2675df1461dfc06a2675df1461&js_challenge=1&token=7afd7253fec22262ff1c52b1703fe9ec1b5c0be6faef3a5c8e49a1e48c0baeb3&jsc_orig_r=|archive-date=2026-06-13|access-date=12 Jun 2026 |website=Reddit}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |date=May 2026 |title=Ya chiquillos. Es hora de detener el AGE CHECK juntos. |trans-title=Ok guys, it's time to stop the AGE CHECK together. |url=https://www.old.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1t6qrh9/ya_chiquillos_es_hora_de_deterner_el_age_check/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20260613011035/https://www.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1t6qrh9/ya_chiquillos_es_hora_de_deterner_el_age_check/?solution=84b9d3b4a9161dc484b9d3b4a9161dc4&js_challenge=1&token=7afd7253fec22262ff1c52b1703fe9ecf85b607bd3e42b2d71525a281a8ace07&jsc_orig_r= |archive-date=2026-06-13 |access-date=12 Jun 2026 |website=Reddit}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |date= |title=Chile copia a Inglaterra la ley "Online Safety Act" de Reino unido , creando la censura total de internet, esta ley es la de mayor alcance desde que existe internet en chile. ellos dicen textualmente que es una copia exacta de la ley inglesa | |||
|trans-title=Chile copies England's "Online Safety Act" from the United Kingdom, creating the total censorship of the internet, this legislation has the highest range since internet exists in Chile. They textually say it is an exact copy of the English law|url=https://www.old.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1t5zw1i/chile_copia_a_inglaterra_la_ley_online_safety_act/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20260613011648/https://www.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1t5zw1i/chile_copia_a_inglaterra_la_ley_online_safety_act/?solution=791394e963b74d25791394e963b74d25&js_challenge=1&token=7afd7253fec22262ff1c52b1703fe9ecdb3b2d2330a3a48f4a53367a500b543e&jsc_orig_r= |archive-date=2026-06-13 |access-date=12 Jun 2026 |website=Reddit}}</ref> | |trans-title=Chile copies England's "Online Safety Act" from the United Kingdom, creating the total censorship of the internet, this legislation has the highest range since internet exists in Chile. They textually say it is an exact copy of the English law|url=https://www.old.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1t5zw1i/chile_copia_a_inglaterra_la_ley_online_safety_act/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20260613011648/https://www.reddit.com/r/chile/comments/1t5zw1i/chile_copia_a_inglaterra_la_ley_online_safety_act/?solution=791394e963b74d25791394e963b74d25&js_challenge=1&token=7afd7253fec22262ff1c52b1703fe9ecdb3b2d2330a3a48f4a53367a500b543e&jsc_orig_r= |archive-date=2026-06-13 |access-date=12 Jun 2026 |website=Reddit}}</ref> | ||
Revision as of 23:26, 15 June 2026
❗This article is a stub. You can help by expanding it.
#appeals channel in either Zulip or Discord to request removal.An article may be flagged as a stub when it is missing major elements needed to make it useful to a reader. You can help by adding missing sections, verifiable sources, relevant company policies and communications, etc. to make the article more complete.
The Safe Digital Environments Law (in Spanish: Ley de Entornos Digitales Seguros) is a proposed legislation in Chile for banning users under the age of 16 from social media.
Background
With many countries establishing social media bans for minors, such as Malaysia with the Malaysia Online Safety Act 2025 (ONSA), Australia and the European Union proposing to do the same, the Chilean government announced in April 2026 the Safe Digital Environments plan to ban users under 16 from social media. [1][2]
Proposals
There's no published bill yet, but proposals for the legislations that have been pushed on Brazil, Australia, France, Spain and the European Union. Mentioned proposals from the ministry point to add mandatory age verification to sites that are social media to prevent underage users to access to these sites. The Social Development & Family Minister, María Jesús Wulf, mentioned there are plans of adding age verification systems implementing the national digital ID, ClaveÚnica, in order to access to social media. Proposals also include to add home and school capacitations to teach about the risks of the internet.[3]
Concerns
This legislation project might be incompatible with aspects from the Chilean constitution and the Net Neutrality Law
According to the Chapter III, Article 19, section 12 of the Chilean Politic Constitution of the Republic, that mentions constitutional rights and duties:[4]
12°. The freedom to emit opinion and informing, without previous censorship, in any form and in any media, without the prejudice to respond to crimes and abuse that are commited in the excercise of these liberties in conformity to the law, that must be qualified quorum.
The law cannot in any case to establish a statal monopoly over social communication media.
The potential imposition of ClaveÚnica to the network services as the only method of age verification can be considered as a statal monopoly, and the prohibition of access to minors to access to social media can be considered as a form of censorship because it potentially can block minors or adults that do not want to verify to access to information in social media.
The possibility that a statal system is controlling the internet services to add age verification measurements, erodes consumer rights over a service they're paying for, restricting the control of the user over the service and their freedom to navigate the net.
Consumer response
The legislation project has received mixed responses and generated a broad debate in media, with some users approving it and other rejecting and critizicing its effectiveness. Experts claim the possibility to implement such age verification systems in the country is something difficult, along with the implementation of ClaveÚnica as the method of age verification raises privacy concerns as the statal system is tied with a person's identity. Johannes Kaiser, representative of the National Libertarian Party (PNL) responded claiming the addition of these restrictions are violating the rigths of privacy and freedom and granting the State to surveil Chileans on the net.[5][6]
Several users in social media, specially on Reddit, in the r/chile subreddit have manifested their concerns with privacy, risks of data breaches, censorship concerns and concerns about the potential expansion of the ban to more sites of the internet, as the project is looking to follow similar international legislations. Some users have also highlighted the incompatibility of the project with the Net Neutrality Law, an established law that prevents telecommunication services to arbitrarily block, interfere or restrict the access to legal content online.[7][8][9]
Government response
According to María Jesús Wulf, the bill has "no objective to limit or restrict childrens' own liberties and rights, but protecting them from harassment and harmful influences online". Also she claims the implementations of ClaveÚnica are only "to verify age and not identity".[10][11]
References
- ↑ Palazzo, Mauricio (27 Apr 2026). "Chile busca limitar el acceso en redes sociales a menores de 16 años" [Chile seeks to limit the access to social media to minors under 16]. Infobae. Archived from the original on 2026-04-28. Retrieved 12 Jun 2026.
- ↑ Jiménez, Macarena (26 Apr 2026). ""Plan Entornos Digitales Seguros": Ministerio del Desarrollo Social presentará proyecto para restringir redes sociales a menores" ["Safe Digital Environments Plan": Social Development Ministry will present project for restricting social media to minors]. Tele 13. Archived from the original on 2026-06-13. Retrieved 12 Jun 2026.
- ↑ "Para proteger a tus hijos en internet: Así es el Plan Nacional de Entornos Digitales Seguros" [To protect your children in internet: This is the National Plan of Safe Digital Environments]. El América. Edición El América.cl. 25 May 2026. Archived from the original on 2026-06-12. Retrieved 12 Jun 2026.
- ↑ https://www.camara.cl/camara/doc/leyes_normas/constitucion.pdf
- ↑ Campos, Sofía (15 Jun 2026). "¿Más protección o vulneración de derechos? Uso de ClaveÚnica para redes sociales de menores abre debate entre expertos" [More protection or rights vulneration? Usage of ClaveÚnica for social media for minors opens debate amongst experts]. Emol. Archived from the original on 2026-06-15. Retrieved 15 Jun 2026.
- ↑ apellido, nombre (13 Jun 2026). "¿Ingreso de menores a RR.SS. mediante Clave Única?: La idea del Gobierno que abrió debate entre expertos" [Minors accessing to social media using Clave Única?: The Government's idea that opened a debate among experts]. Emol. Archived from the original on 2026-06-15. Retrieved 15 Jun 2026.
- ↑ "Ministra Wulf adelantó posible control de edad en RRSS a través de ClaveÚnica: qué se sabe hasta ahora" [Minister Wulf forwarded possible age control on social media trough ClaveÚnica: what it is known for now]. Reddit. Archived from the original on 2026-06-13. Retrieved 12 Jun 2026.
- ↑ "Ya chiquillos. Es hora de detener el AGE CHECK juntos" [Ok guys, it's time to stop the AGE CHECK together.]. Reddit. May 2026. Archived from the original on 2026-06-13. Retrieved 12 Jun 2026.
- ↑ "Chile copia a Inglaterra la ley "Online Safety Act" de Reino unido , creando la censura total de internet, esta ley es la de mayor alcance desde que existe internet en chile. ellos dicen textualmente que es una copia exacta de la ley inglesa" [Chile copies England's "Online Safety Act" from the United Kingdom, creating the total censorship of the internet, this legislation has the highest range since internet exists in Chile. They textually say it is an exact copy of the English law]. Reddit. Archived from the original on 2026-06-13. Retrieved 12 Jun 2026.
- ↑ ""ClaveÚnica en redes": Gobierno evalúa verificar edad de menores" ["Claveúnica in media": Government evaluates to verify age of minors]. Diario el Día. 12 Jun 2026. Archived from the original on 2026-06-13. Retrieved 12 Jun 2026.
- ↑ Haas, Bárbara (12 Jun 2026). "Ministra Wulf adelantó posible control de edad en RRSS a través de ClaveÚnica: qué se sabe hasta ahora" [Minister Wulf forwarded a possible age control in social media trough ClaveÚnica: what is known for now]. Bío Bío Chile. Archived from the original on 2026-06-13. Retrieved 12 Jun 2026.