Jump to content

Brilliant SmartThings subscription requirement

From Consumer Rights Wiki

In November 2026, smart-home equipment manufacturer Brilliant NextGen announced that owners would need a paid Brilliant Max subscription to keep using its integration with Samsung SmartThings.[citation needed] The integration had been available on Brilliant smart-home controls for years without that subscription.[1][2][3] Starting in December 2026, customers who do not subscribe are expected to lose the ability to control compatible third-party devices through Brilliant, including equipment they connected before the change was announced.[4][3] Brilliant advertised Max at $9.99 per month or $99.99 per year as of 15 November 2026.[5]

The dispute concerns a change to the terms of using existing hardware: customers who bought Brilliant controls partly for their compatibility with other smart-home products face a new recurring charge to retain that compatibility. The restriction does not mean that the Brilliant panels or the third-party devices themselves will stop functioning.[6][3]

Background

[edit | edit source]

Brilliant's wall-mounted Control panels combine a touchscreen and lighting controls with the ability to operate devices made by other manufacturers. The product was sold in one- through four-gang versions, and the company also offers dimmer switches, plugs and a mobile application.[1][3] Rather than requiring customers to use only Brilliant-branded equipment, its SmartThings integration allowed compatible products from different brands to be operated together from the same interface.[3]

SmartThings compatibility was not introduced as a Brilliant Max feature. A PCWorld review from September 2018 listed SmartThings among the original Control's integrations. In August 2023, The Verge described using a Brilliant panel with Lutron Caséta switches connected through SmartThings.[1][2] These accounts establish that the integration predated the paid Max service by several years.

Brilliant later introduced Brilliant Max as a subscription for additional automation features, including automated modes and personalized setups. The company's Max marketing emphasizes those newer services.[5] The SmartThings change is different: it places a subscription requirement on an integration that customers could already use, rather than charging solely for newly introduced features.[1][3][6]

Subscription requirement

[edit | edit source]

Brilliant's SmartThings support article says the integration will require Brilliant Max starting in December 2026. Its Lutron product page gives a more specific date of 3 December 2026 and says that all brands connected to Brilliant through SmartThings will require an active subscription, not just Lutron.[3][4] A customer posting on Reddit reported receiving an email specifying 2 December instead. That date is an unverified account of a customer notice; Brilliant's publicly accessible Lutron page gives 3 December.[7][4]

Brilliant separates its integrations into standard and premium categories. The company says integrations routed through Samsung SmartThings belong to the premium category and require Brilliant Max beginning in December 2026.[6] For an existing customer, this means that retaining the same connection between previously installed products becomes conditional on an additional payment.

Affected products and functions

[edit | edit source]

The restriction is tied to the SmartThings connection, not to every product sold by the affected manufacturers. Brilliant's documentation describes two directions of integration: SmartThings-compatible lights, switches, locks and shades can appear on a Brilliant Control, while the SmartThings app can operate lights connected to Brilliant Controls or Dimmer Switches and devices connected to Brilliant Plugs.[3] Brilliant has not separately documented the exact effect of the new paywall on every direction of communication or every model.

For devices connected to a Brilliant Control through SmartThings, documented features include control from the panel's room interface, assigning compatible lights to sliders or screen gestures, adding devices to Brilliant scenes, and controlling them remotely through Brilliant's mobile app.[3] Losing that connection can therefore affect more than a single on-screen button: an existing scene or control arrangement may no longer operate as configured unless the owner subscribes.

Brilliant specifically identifies Lutron Caséta switches and Lutron Serena shades as products connected through SmartThings. Its Lutron page says those connections require Brilliant Max from 3 December 2026.[4][8] The general requirement also applies to other compatible brands whose devices reach Brilliant through SmartThings.[4][6] Devices using a separate direct Brilliant integration should not be assumed to be affected merely because they share a manufacturer's name.

This does not mean that the connected lights, locks or shades are themselves disabled. They may still be controllable using SmartThings or their manufacturers' own applications. What owners stand to lose is the ability to use those devices through Brilliant's interface and any Brilliant functions dependent on that connection.[3]

Cost to existing owners

[edit | edit source]

As of 15 November 2026, Brilliant advertised Max at $9.99 per month or $99.99 per year, per home rather than per installed panel, with a 30-day trial for new subscribers.[5] Twelve monthly payments total $119.88. Five years at the advertised annual price would cost $499.95, assuming the price remains unchanged. For comparison, Brilliant listed its single-gang Control for $599 on its Lutron page in November 2026; this is a contemporary list price, not necessarily what earlier buyers paid.[4]

The extra expense is not the price of buying a new accessory or installing additional equipment. It is the cost of keeping a software connection that was previously available on purchased hardware. Owners who decline the subscription retain their devices but are expected to lose the affected Brilliant integration.[3][4] Customers with several connected devices or routines may also need to change how they operate their home if they choose not to pay.

Brilliant's terms state that a free trial converts into an automatically renewing paid subscription unless canceled before the trial ends. Cancellation prevents the next renewal but does not produce a prorated refund for unused time. The terms also allow Brilliant to change Max pricing with at least 30 days' notice.[9] Consequently, the ongoing cost of retaining SmartThings access is not fixed by the original hardware purchase or by the subscription's introductory price.

Manufacturer control over purchased hardware

[edit | edit source]

The change illustrates the distinction between owning a physical smart-home controller and controlling the software services on which some of its features depend. A customer may own a functioning Brilliant panel and compatible third-party devices yet no longer be entitled to use the same connection between them without a subscription.[3][4]

Brilliant's terms permit software updates to be installed automatically without additional notice or consent and state that some third-party integrations require an active Max subscription. The terms also provide for suspension of Max features when payment is not received.[9] These provisions leave access to software-dependent functions subject to Brilliant's continuing policies. They do not, by themselves, establish which technical method Brilliant will use to enforce the December 2026 restriction; no particular firmware update has been verified as its enforcement mechanism.

The issue is therefore not simply that Brilliant sells a subscription. Brilliant Max also offers new automation services, which customers may choose to purchase.[5] The ownership concern is the retroactive subscription requirement for an established integration that formed part of the hardware's practical usefulness before the subscription existed.[1][2][4]

Customer response and alternatives

[edit | edit source]

On 4 November 2026, a Reddit user who said they owned two Brilliant Controls reported receiving notice of the new requirement. The user described replacing the touchscreen application on their panels with a Home Assistant-based interface rather than paying to preserve the existing integration, and published code for the project.[7] This is one owner's account and an experimental workaround, not evidence that all Brilliant customers can install the same software or retain every original feature.

The response demonstrates a practical concern raised by the change: an owner who wants to avoid recurring fees may need to reconfigure existing smart-home devices, adopt another control platform, or use unsupported modifications to equipment already installed in the home. The availability and suitability of alternatives depend on the customer's particular devices and technical skills.[7][3]

Company position and status

[edit | edit source]

Brilliant publicly describes SmartThings as a premium integration and directs customers to Brilliant Max. Its product pages distinguish premium SmartThings-based integrations from standard integrations; they do not state that all Brilliant functions require a subscription.[6][4] Brilliant Max's own marketing emphasizes additional automation capabilities, while the SmartThings notice makes continued access to an existing connection contingent on paying for that broader subscription.[5][3]

As of 15 November 2026, the announced December change had not yet taken effect. The available documentation establishes the planned requirement but not the precise post-cutoff behavior of every device, whether existing configurations will be retained indefinitely without payment, or whether Brilliant will offer exceptions for earlier purchasers.

References

[edit | edit source]
  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Null, Christopher (2018-09-06). "Brilliant Control review: Impressive blend of switch and smart home controller". PCWorld. Retrieved 2026-11-15.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Pattison Tuohy, Jennifer (2023-08-22). "Brilliant's new smart home controller makes it easier to put a touchscreen on your wall". The Verge. Retrieved 2026-11-15.
  3. ↑ 3.00 3.01 3.02 3.03 3.04 3.05 3.06 3.07 3.08 3.09 3.10 3.11 3.12 3.13 "SmartThings Integration". Brilliant Support. Brilliant NextGen. Retrieved 2026-11-15.
  4. ↑ 4.00 4.01 4.02 4.03 4.04 4.05 4.06 4.07 4.08 4.09 "Works with Lutron". Brilliant. Brilliant NextGen. Retrieved 2026-11-15.
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 "Brilliant Max". Brilliant. Brilliant NextGen. Retrieved 2026-11-15.
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 "Brilliant works with a wide range of smart home products". Brilliant. Brilliant NextGen. Retrieved 2026-11-15.
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 "Home Assistant driven Brilliant Home Panels". Reddit. 2026-11-04. Retrieved 2026-11-15.
  8. ↑ "Lutron Integration through SmartThings". Brilliant Support. Brilliant NextGen. Retrieved 2026-11-15.
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 "Terms of Service". Brilliant. Brilliant NextGen. March 2026. Retrieved 2026-11-15.